General Information & Client Service
  • Americas: +1.212.553.1653
  • Asia: +852.3551.3077
  • China: +86.10.6319.6580
  • EMEA: +44.20.7772.5454
  • Japan: +81.3.5408.4100
Media Relations
  • New York: +1.212.553.0376
  • London: +44.20.7772.5456
  • Hong Kong: +852.3758.1350
  • Tokyo: +813.5408.4110
  • Sydney: +61.2.9270.8141
  • Mexico City: +001.888.779.5833
  • Buenos Aires: +0800.666.3506
  • São Paulo: +0800.891.2518
August 04, 2017

IMF published a working paper that compares the regulatory capital requirements under the Dodd-Frank Act and the 10% leverage ratio, as proposed by the U.S. Treasury and the U.S. House of Representatives' Financial CHOICE Act (FCA). The paper also highlights the potential for regulatory arbitrage by banks and the associated moral hazard problem that arises due to the option of the FCA qualifying banking organizations.

The paper undertakes certain exercises to assess the qualifying banks option. It uses balance sheet data on the types of banks (by asset size) that would qualify for the off-ramp under the FCA and estimates how much capital banks would need to add to qualify for the “off-ramp” regulation. Then, to surmise whether there could be a self-selection of more risk-prone banks in the off-ramp, the paper analyzes the balance sheet characteristics of banks with a relatively small capital gap to the 10% leverage ratio. The analysis identifies an important moral hazard problem that arises due to the qualifying banks' optionality, where banks are likely to increase the riskiness of their asset portfolio and qualify for the FCA “off-ramp” relief, with unintended effects on financial stability. This moral hazard problem would manifest through banks increasing the RWA imprint in their balance sheet through increased risk taking, thereby qualifying for the “off-ramp” regulatory relief, under which banks hold 10% leverage ratio while enjoying higher expected returns and lower regulatory costs. This would make the banks riskier and, due to smaller capital buffers, less resilient to adverse shocks.

 

However, the results show that small banks (total assets below USD 3 billion) with capital gaps to the qualifying banks threshold would tend not to opt for the “off-ramp.” Despite the stated intention of policymakers to provide regulatory relief for small banks under the proposed FCA, this paper concludes that these banks would opt to stay under the existing Dodd-Frank Act regime. Investors and the market would expect large and globally active banks to meet modern regulatory standards. Also, banks that can have large maturity mismatches and a fewer share of highly liquid assets than demanded under the Dodd-Frank Act or Basel III would be less attractive as a counterpart in the interbank market. Finally, it is also clear that reliance on regulation alone (Pillar 1) cannot be sufficient. Supervisors (Pillar 2) need to continue to increase market discipline (Pillar 3) and transparency, and help financial institutions increase internal risk management capacity and capital planning.

 

Related Link: Working Paper (PDF)

Keywords: Americas, United States of America, Banking, Dodd Frank Act, Basel III, Capital Requirements, Regulatory Arbitrage, IMF

Related Articles
News

HKMA Decides to Maintain Countercyclical Capital Buffer at 2.5%

HKMA announced that, in accordance with the Banking (Capital) Rules, the countercyclical capital buffer (CCyB) ratio for Hong Kong remains at 2.5%.

April 16, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
News

EP Approves Agreement on Package of CRD 5, CRR 2, BRRD 2, and SRMR 2

The European Parliament (EP) approved the final agreement on a package of reforms proposed by EC to strengthen the resilience and resolvability of European banks.

April 16, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
News

FDIC Consults on Approach to Resolution Planning for IDIs

FDIC approved an Advance Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (ANPR) and is seeking comment on ways to tailor and improve its rule requiring certain insured depository institutions (IDIs) to submit resolution plans.

April 16, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
News

EP Resolution on Proposal for Sovereign Bond Backed Securities

The European Parliament (EP) published adopted text on the proposal for a regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council on sovereign bond-backed securities (SBBS).

April 16, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
News

PRA Seeks Input and Issues Specifications for Insurance Stress Tests

PRA announced that it will conduct an insurance stress test for the largest regulated life and general insurers from July to September 2019.

April 15, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
News

PRA Finalizes Policy on Approach to Managing Climate Change Risks

PRA published the policy statement PS11/19, which contains final supervisory statement (SS3/19) on enhancing banks’ and insurers’ approaches to managing the financial risks from climate change (Appendix).

April 15, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
News

EBA Single Rulebook Q&A: First Update for April 2019

EBA published answers to nine questions under the Single Rulebook question and answer (Q&A) updates for this week.

April 12, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
News

EIOPA Statement on Application of Proportionality in SCR Supervision

EIOPA published a supervisory statement on the application of proportionality principle in the supervision of the Solvency Capital Requirement (SCR) calculated in accordance with the standard formula.

April 11, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
News

FED Updates Form and Supplemental Instructions for FR Y-9C Reporting

FED updated the form and supplemental instructions for FR Y-9C reporting. FR Y-9C is used to collect data from domestic bank holding companies, savings and loan holding companies, U.S intermediate holding companies, and securities holding companies with total consolidated assets of USD 3 billion or more.

April 11, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
News

OSFI Finalizes Guidelines on Liquidity Adequacy and NSFR Disclosures

OSFI published the final Liquidity Adequacy Requirements (LAR) guideline and the net stable funding ratio (NSFR) disclosure requirements guideline.

April 11, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
RESULTS 1 - 10 OF 2929