David Rule of BoE Discusses Issues in Insurance Supervision
At a conference in London, David Rule, the Executive Director of Insurance at BoE offered an update on progress toward a global Insurance Capital Standard (ICS) and discussed the fledgling UK market for Insurance-Linked Securities and the new insurers unit of BoE. He also reiterated the messages on underwriting and reserving in wholesale insurance and reinsurance markets from Anna Sweeney’s Dear CEO letter earlier this year, discussed capital management, shared data on the sensitivity of the capital surpluses of UK life insurers to various market movements, and encouraged more consistency in disclosure of sensitivities by insurers and the drivers of changes in their capital positions over time.
Mr. Rule emphasized that BoE supports the development of international regulatory standards, such as the ICS. As both a home supervisor of UK insurance groups with businesses worldwide and a host supervisor of branches and subsidiaries of insurance groups from many different countries, he also welcomed the monitoring period (starting in 2020) approach of IAIS. During this period, the Internationally Active Insurance Groups will report a reference ICS confidentially to their group-wide supervisors, including for discussion in regulatory colleges. This will give regulatory colleges a common language for measuring group risk and defining capital. He said: "No capital framework is perfect and ICS will be no different. But having agreement on common metrics will be a big step forward. It should further enhance supervisory cooperation and help build trust. Over time, it might reduce the need for multiple overlapping practices in measuring the same risks and help to limit fragmentation of capital requirements."
PRA will also be alert to insurers seeking to reduce capital requirements through aggressive changes to internal models or over-optimistic business plans, suggested Mr. Rule. This includes using the internal model output data to compare across insurers and monitoring model "drift" indicators, such as the ratio of internal model to standard formula capital requirements. He added that during a roundtable with insurance analysts and investors on disclosure around a year ago, it was found that insurers find Solvency II disclosures more useful than accounting disclosures, at least in the current state of insurance accounting. A consistent set of market sensitivities was near the top of their disclosure wish list. He added that he hopes that insurers and industry groups will work toward an industry standard in this area, perhaps drawing on what they already report.
He mentioned market risk sensitivities and a Solvency II "P&L" as the two areas where insurers could improve the quality and consistency of disclosures. He used the term "Solvency II P&L" to refer to the drivers of the change in insurers' Solvency Capital Requirement (SCR) coverage ratio from one reporting date to another. However, Solvency II does not address measurement of changes in capital position over time. There is a reporting gap and insurers are closing it with their own content, leading to a mixed picture across the sector. Again, this is an area where insurers and industry groups could usefully develop some template approaches. He added that it is a concern that we still see evidence of analysts and investors not fully understanding Solvency II balance sheets of insurers. In more stressed market conditions complexity and lack of transparency might lead investors to turn away from regulatory measures of risk and rely on simpler but cruder approaches. However, progress toward an international capital standard should help with this.
Related Link: Speech
Keywords: Europe, UK, Insurance, Solvency II, Disclosures, SCR, Insurance Supervision, BoE
Previous Article
ECB Publishes Guidance Notes to Reporting Agents on SHS RegulationRelated Insights
|
News
IAIS Publishes Drafts of Revised ICP 8, ICP 15, ICP 16, and ICP 20IAIS published the drafts of revised Insurance Core Principles on Public Disclosure (ICP 20), Investments (ICP 15), Enterprise Risk Management for Solvency Purposes (ICP 16), and Risk Management and Internal Controls (ICP 8), along with a revised draft of the glossary on enterprise risk management (ERM).
November 14, 2018
WebPage
Regulatory News
|
|
News
MAS Amends Notice 637 on Capital Adequacy Requirements in SingaporeMAS published the final, revised Notice 637 on the risk-based capital adequacy requirements in Singapore.
November 13, 2018
WebPage
Regulatory News
|
|
News
ESMA Updates Q&A on Implementation of CSD Regulation and MARESMA updated questions and answers (Q&A) documents on the implementation of the Central Securities Depository (CSD) Regulation and Market Abuse Regulation (MAR).
November 12, 2018
WebPage
Regulatory News
|
|
News
FSB Finalizes and Publishes the Cyber LexiconFSB published a cyber lexicon, following the public consultation earlier this year.
November 12, 2018
WebPage
Regulatory News
|
|
News
SRB Updates Liability Data Reporting Template for 2019SRB published version 2.7.1 of the Liability Data Reporting (LDR) Template.
November 12, 2018
WebPage
Regulatory News
|
|
News
ECB to Conduct Comprehensive Assessment of Six Bulgarian BanksECB will undertake a comprehensive assessment of six Bulgarian banks. The exercise, comprising an asset quality review and a stress test, follows Bulgaria’s submission of a request to establish close cooperation with ECB on July 18, 2018.
November 12, 2018
WebPage
Regulatory News
|
|
News
IMF Publishes Reports on the 2018 Article IV Consultation with ChileIMF published its staff report and selected issues report under the 2018 Article IV consultation with Chile.
November 09, 2018
WebPage
Regulatory News
|
|
News
PRA Issues PS27/18 on Implementing the Extension of SM&CR to InsurersPRA published the policy statement PS27/18, which provides feedback to responses to the consultation paper CP20/18, on implementing the extension of the Senior Managers and Certification Regime (SM&CR) to insurers (Part 2).
November 09, 2018
WebPage
Regulatory News
|
|
News
EBA Single Rulebook Q&A: First Update for November 2018EBA published answers to seven questions under the Single Rulebook question and answer (Q&A) updates for this week.
November 09, 2018
WebPage
Regulatory News
|
|
News
FED Finalizes the Large Financial Institution Rating SystemFED finalized the new supervisory rating system for Large Financial Institutions (LFIs), to better align with the current supervisory programs and practices for these firms.
November 09, 2018
WebPage
Regulatory News
|
