IMF Note Assesses Cooperative Bank and Credit Union Sectors in Poland
IMF published, under the Financial Sector Assessment Program (FSAP), a technical note on cooperative banks and credit unions in the Republic of Poland. The technical note reviews the situation in cooperative bank and credit union sectors, both of which are in states of transition; the regulatory and supervisory arrangements; and the safety net and resolution regime within the context of the crisis management framework. The note also offers perspectives on the sustainability of institutional models and these sectors within a modernizing and competitive banking sector.
The note highlights that most cooperative banks and credit unions are stable, but each sector has its own issues. The FSAP is broadly supportive of the policy direction for cooperatives, while it questions whether the credit union sector should remain standalone. Combined, cooperative banks and credit unions represent less than 8% of deposit takers, though more importantly they serve about 18% of the population. The overall situation of most cooperative banks is that they remain well-capitalized, with moderate levels of non-performing loans (NPLs) largely in line with the overall banking system, though with weak profitability. The NPLs are noted to be higher among larger cooperative banks, which represent about 65% of the cooperative bank sector assets. A vast majority of cooperative banks meet the regulatory capital requirements but raising capital from members or external sources, when needed, is complicated by applicable regulations and the dividend policies of cooperative banks.
Despite improvements in recent years, the performance of credit unions and the quality of their financial information is not yet satisfactory. Since coming under the supervision by Polish Financial Supervision Authority (PFSA), there has been some improvement in the credit union sector mainly due to the resolution of nonviable credit unions and better performance of the remaining entities. These improvements, however, are not sufficient to reverse the deterioration in the system thus far. The capital adequacy of the credit union sector at the end of January 2018 remains below the regulatory minimum of 5%, reflecting the troubled situation of larger credit unions. The source of low capital adequacy has been losses from poor loan underwriting and a series of past mergers that were allowed without addressing viability issues.
The technical note contains a table that summarizes several key recommendations to authorities in Poland. These recommendations relate to supervision and reforms in the cooperative bank and credit union sectors. The key recommendations with respect to supervision are as follows:
- Strengthen the supervisory capacity of PFSA by increasing (at least during a transition period) the available resources to oversee the cooperative banks and credit union sectors.
- Strengthen the quality of the Institutional Protection Scheme internal control and audit practices to align with PFSA supervisory requirements. Moreover, each affiliating bank should meet higher capital requirements.
- Revise the reporting requirements and supervision methodologies for cooperative banks and credit unions to ensure proportionality as far as feasible under applicable EU regulations.
- Evaluate the definition of criteria for auditors of the different institutions; if feasible, establish a short list of qualified auditors for the different types of entities, considering their complexity.
- Further enhance the monitoring by the Institutional Protection Scheme, align methodologies with PFSA.
- Further enhance the monitoring of all cooperative banks—including through a shortening in the supervisory inspection cycle—until relevant capacity is established in the Institutional Protection Schemes.
- Identify additional cooperative bank capital instruments that are compatible within the EU Capital Requirements Regulation or CRR.
- Unify accounting standards among sectors and institutions.
Related Link: Technical Note
Keywords: Europe, EU, Poland, Banking, FSAP, Technical Note, Credit Unions, Cooperative Banks, PFSA, Proportionality, CRR, IMF
Related Articles
FINMA Approves Merger of Credit Suisse and UBS
The Swiss Financial Market Supervisory Authority (FINMA) has approved the takeover of Credit Suisse by UBS.
BOE Sets Out Its Thinking on Regulatory Capital and Climate Risks
The Bank of England (BOE) published a working paper that aims to understand the climate-related disclosures of UK financial institutions.
OSFI Finalizes on Climate Risk Guideline, Issues Other Updates
The Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions (OSFI) is seeking comments, until May 31, 2023, on the draft guideline on culture and behavior risk, with final guideline expected by the end of 2023.
APRA Assesses Macro-Prudential Policy Settings, Issues Other Updates
The Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA) published an information paper that assesses its macro-prudential policy settings aimed at promoting stability at a systemic level.
BIS Paper Examines Impact of Greenhouse Gas Emissions on Lending
BIS issued a paper that investigates the effect of the greenhouse gas, or GHG, emissions of firms on bank loans using bank–firm matched data of Japanese listed firms from 2006 to 2018.
HMT Mulls Alignment of Ring-Fencing and Resolution Regimes for Banks
The HM Treasury (HMT) is seeking evidence, until May 07, 2023, on practicalities of aligning the ring-fencing and the banking resolution regimes for banks.
MFSA Sets Out Supervisory Priorities, Issues Reporting Updates
The Malta Financial Services Authority (MFSA) outlined its supervisory priorities for 2023
German Regulators Issue Multiple Reporting Updates for Banks
Deutsche Bundesbank published the nationally deactivated validation rules for the German Commercial Code (HGB) users on the taxonomy 3.2, which became valid from December 31, 2022
BCBS Report Examines Impact of Basel III Framework for Banks
The Basel Committee on Banking Supervision (BCBS) published results of the Basel III monitoring exercise based on the June 30, 2022 data.
PRA Consults on Prudential Rules for "Simpler-Regime" Firms
Among the recent regulatory updates from UK authorities, a key development is the first-phase consultation, from the Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA), on simplifications to the prudential framework that would apply to the simpler-regime firms.