Featured Product

    Randal Quarles of FED on Trends in Urban and Rural Community Banks

    October 04, 2018

    While speaking at the sixth Annual Community Banking Research and Policy Conference in Missouri, Randal K. Quarles of FED said that the numbers of urban and rural community banks have been declining over the past 20 years, but community banks continue to play an important role in both types of markets and they still account for over 95% of banks operating in the United States. He discussed the differences among community banks in terms of size and markets served (urban versus rural) and emphasized that community banks operating in rural and urban areas tend to face different challenges.

    The number of banks in the United States fell by almost half over the past 20 years—from about 10,700 in 1997 to about 5,600 in 2017. About 97% of the decrease was accounted for by community banks. Although the number of banks in both of these categories has been falling over time, the rate of decline was steeper for rural banks than for urban banks before the financial crisis but has reversed in the post-crisis period. In terms of performance measures, rural community banks consistently outperform urban community banks with regard to return on assets and return on equity. This difference was particularly pronounced during the financial crisis, when profitability fell much more sharply at urban community banks than at rural community banks. The data suggest that, despite facing a more challenging economic environment, rural community banks appear to be holding their own relative to urban community banks. Even if the data indicate that most rural markets are well-served, focus should be on the markets that may not be as well-served and how that is affecting the people who bank, or cannot bank, there. That is why the Community Development function of FED has undertaken a national series of listening sessions to assess the real effects of bank closures on rural communities. 

    For residents in a particular community, the closure has not been much of a problem, as they do most of their routine banking online and even noted that they did not think automated teller machines (ATMs) were necessary because most of the retail businesses in town offer cash back with debit card purchases. Nonetheless, residents spoke positively about the importance of the personal touch a local bank can provide. Residents liked familiar faces at the teller window and loan officers who understand the local economy when making small business loan decisions. Moreover, online banking is not necessarily an opportunity for everyone, depending, for example, on whether the necessary infrastructure is available. In Nicholas County, Kentucky, many residents do not have access to high-speed internet; this lack of access has led most residents to travel outside of the county to conduct their banking needs. This situation is certainly not optimal for anyone, but it presents a particular challenge to the elderly, those without a car, and busy small business owners who do not have time to travel 25 miles each way to make change and deposit checks. 

    The loss of a bank branch also has a ripple effect on a community as a whole. In the village of Brushton, New York, which lost its only bank branch in 2014, small business owners commented that when residents must leave the village to access banking services, they are more likely to shop, eat, and pay for services in other towns, which creates additional hardship for the small businesses of Brushton. Additionally, as the ability of community members to access cash has decreased, credit card use has increased. Small business owners in Brushton say that this growth in credit card usage has significantly increased the cost of doing business. Lastly, one theme that was clear across the country was that the loss of a local bank meant the loss of an important civic institution. Banks do not just cash checks and make loans—they also place ads in small town newspapers, donate to local nonprofits, and sponsor local Little League teams. As towns lose banks and bankers, they also lose important local leaders. He reiterated that FED will continue to explore challenges faced by local communities and looks forward to sharing the collective results of these efforts in a report that should be published in early 2019.

     

    Related Link: Speech

    Keywords: Americas, US, Banking, Community Banks, Urban Banks, Rural Banks, Trends, FED

     

    Related Articles
    News

    APRA Updates Lists of Validation and Derivation Rules in December 2019

    APRA updated the lists of the Direct to APRA (D2A) validation and derivation rules for authorized deposit-taking institutions, insurers, and superannuation entities.

    December 13, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
    News

    APRA Finalizes Prudential Standard for Credit Risk Management of Banks

    APRA updated the prudential standard on credit risk management requirements (APS 220) for authorized deposit-taking institutions, post a public consultation.

    December 12, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
    News

    EIOPA Consults on Guidelines on ICT Security and Governance

    EIOPA issued a consultation on guidelines on the Information and Communication Technology (ICT) security and governance by insurers.

    December 12, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
    News

    BCBS Consults on Design of Prudential Treatment for Crypto-Assets

    BCBS published a discussion paper on the design of prudential treatment for crypto-asset exposures of banks.

    December 12, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
    News

    NCUA Approves Delay of Risk-Based Capital Rules Until January 2022

    The NCUA Board held its eleventh open meeting of 2019 and approved a final rule to delay the effective date of the risk-based capital rules for credit unions to January 01, 2022.

    December 12, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
    News

    APRA Issues Operational Risk Rules, Consults on Reporting Requirements

    APRA published an updated prudential standard APS 115 that sets out operational risk requirements for authorized deposit-taking institutions in Australia.

    December 11, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
    News

    ESMA Updates Q&A on European Benchmarks Regulation in December 2019

    ESMA updated the question and answers (Q&A) document on the European Benchmarks Regulation.

    December 11, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
    News

    APRA Decides to Keep Countercyclical Capital Buffer for Banks at 0%

    APRA announced its decision to keep the countercyclical capital buffer (CCyB) for authorized deposit-taking institutions on hold at zero percent.

    December 11, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
    News

    ESMA on Draft Amendments to Indices and Recognized Exchanges Under CRR

    ESMA issued the final report on draft amendments to the Implementing Regulation (EU) 2016/1646, which specifies the main indices and recognized exchanges, under the Capital Requirements Regulation (CRR), that are relevant to credit institutions and investment firms subject to prudential requirements and trading venues.

    December 11, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
    News

    FED Extends Consultation Period for Capital Requirements for Insurers

    FED is extending comment period for the proposed rule establishing risk-based capital requirements for depository institution holding companies that are significantly engaged in insurance activities.

    December 10, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
    RESULTS 1 - 10 OF 4316