ECB Recommends Changes to Proposed Rules on Artificial Intelligence
The European Central Bank (ECB) published an opinion on the proposal for a regulation laying down harmonized rules on artificial intelligence or AI (Artificial Intelligence Act) and amending certain European Union legislative acts (hereafter the "proposed regulation"). This opinion is in response to a request from the European Council for an opinion on the proposed regulation. In the opinion, ECB welcomes the overall proposal and sets out recommendations, along with a specific drafting proposal, to amend the proposed regulation on artificial intelligence.
ECB welcomes the objective of the proposed regulation to improve the functioning of the internal market by laying down a uniform legal framework for the development, marketing, and use of trustworthy artificial intelligence in conformity with the European Union values. ECB also welcomes the proposed regulation’s intention to avoid overlaps with the existing legislative framework by subsuming some of its provisions into the relevant provisions of the Capital Requirements Directive (CRD). Concerning high-risk artificial intelligence systems provided or used by credit institutions, ECB understands that the proposed regulation integrates certain obligations into the procedures set out in CRD. In particular, the proposed regulation aims to enhance consistency with the CRD by integrating some of the providers’ and users’ risk management and governance obligations into the internal governance system of credit institutions. Because of the novelty and complexity of artificial intelligence and the high-level standards of the proposed regulation, ECB opines that further guidance is necessary to clarify supervisory expectations with regard to the obligations in relation to internal governance.
Under the proposed regulation, the vast majority of credit scoring activities making use of artificial intelligence systems would be automatically subjected to the horizontal minimum requirements imposed on high-risk artificial intelligence systems. Consequently, several activities, including acquisition targeting for marketing, collections modeling, and standard credit scoring models would need to comply with the same requirements. To enhance clarity in supervisory expectations and in line with the technology-neutral approach of ECB, it is suggested that artificial intelligence systems intended to be used to evaluate the creditworthiness of natural persons or establish their credit score should not be classified as high-risk artificial intelligence systems, provided that the impact of such approaches to the assessment of natural persons’ creditworthiness or credit score is minor. As credit scoring activities are regularly carried out by credit institutions in day-to-day practice, ECB suggests that the entry into effect of requirements that relate to the qualification of artificial intelligence systems intended to be used to evaluate the creditworthiness of natural persons or establish their credit score as "high-risk artificial intelligence systems" should be delayed until the adoption, by the European Commission, of common specifications on the matter. In particular, these common specifications should spell out the conditions under which high-risk systems in this field will be presumed to be in conformity with the applicable requirements. The common specifications should also define when artificial intelligence systems should be considered as "put into service by small scale providers for their own use" and, therefore, fall within the scope of the exception from the qualification as a high-risk artificial intelligence system.
Thus, the opinion notes that ECB should be included in the list of bodies consulted before the adoption of such common specifications, where they concern artificial intelligence systems intended to be used to evaluate the creditworthiness of natural persons or establish their credit score. ECB welcomes the possibility to update the list of high-risk artificial intelligence systems included in Annex III to the proposed regulation. ECB also emphasizes that the proposed regulation should be without prejudice to the more specific or stringent prudential obligations of credit institutions set out in sectoral regulation and supplemented by supervisory guidance. ECB would welcome further clarifications regarding the applicable requirements and competent authorities with regard to outsourcing by credit institution users of high-risk artificial intelligence systems. ECB also highlights that its role under the proposed regulation should be clarified, in particular on its general prudential supervisory competency in relation to the market surveillance and conformity assessment, and on the application of the proposed regulation to the performance of the ECB tasks under the Treaty.
Related Link: Opinion (PDF)
Keywords: Europe, EU, Banking, Artificial Intelligence, CRD, Basel, Credit Scoring, Opinion, Regtech, Lending, Loan Origination, Fintech, Suptech, ECB
Featured Experts
María Cañamero
Skilled market researcher; growth strategist; successful go-to-market campaign developer
Nicolas Degruson
Works with financial institutions, regulatory experts, business analysts, product managers, and software engineers to drive regulatory solutions across the globe.
Patrycja Oleksza
Applies proficiency and knowledge to regulatory capital and reporting analysis and coordinates business and product strategies in the banking technology area
Related Articles
BIS and Central Banks Experiment with GenAI to Assess Climate Risks
A recent report from the Bank for International Settlements (BIS) Innovation Hub details Project Gaia, a collaboration between the BIS Innovation Hub Eurosystem Center and certain central banks in Europe
Nearly 25% G-SIBs Commit to Adopting TNFD Nature-Related Disclosures
Nature-related risks are increasing in severity and frequency, affecting businesses, capital providers, financial systems, and economies.
Singapore to Mandate Climate Disclosures from FY2025
Singapore recently took a significant step toward turning climate ambition into action, with the introduction of mandatory climate-related disclosures for listed and large non-listed companies
SEC Finalizes Climate-Related Disclosures Rule
The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has finalized the long-awaited rule that mandates climate-related disclosures for domestic and foreign publicly listed companies in the U.S.
EBA Proposes Standards Related to Standardized Credit Risk Approach
The European Banking Authority (EBA) has been taking significant steps toward implementing the Basel III framework and strengthening the regulatory framework for credit institutions in the EU
US Regulators Release Stress Test Scenarios for Banks
The U.S. regulators recently released baseline and severely adverse scenarios, along with other details, for stress testing the banks in 2024. The relevant U.S. banking regulators are the Federal Reserve Bank (FED), the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC), and the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC).
Asian Governments Aim for Interoperability in AI Governance Frameworks
The regulatory landscape for artificial intelligence (AI), including the generative kind, is evolving rapidly, with governments and regulators aiming to address the challenges and opportunities presented by this transformative technology.
EBA Proposes Operational Risk Standards Under Final Basel III Package
The European Union (EU) has been working on the final elements of Basel III standards, with endorsement of the Banking Package and the publication of the European Banking Authority (EBA) roadmap on Basel III implementation in December 2023.
EFRAG Proposes XBRL Taxonomy and Standard for Listed SMEs Under ESRS
The European Financial Reporting Advisory Group (EFRAG), which plays a crucial role in shaping corporate reporting standards in European Union (EU), is seeking comments, until May 21, 2024, on the Exposure Draft ESRS for listed SMEs.
ECB to Expand Climate Change Work in 2024-2025
Banking regulators worldwide are increasingly focusing on addressing, monitoring, and supervising the institutions' exposure to climate and environmental risks.