Don Kohn of BoE spoke at the 200th Anniversary of Danmarks Nationalbank in Copenhagen. In his speech, Don Kohn examines the lessons that can be learned from the last global financial crisis. He believes that complacency in good times can ultimately store up problems for the global economy and financial system. He also emphasized that macro-prudential policy is a promising addition to the regulatory toolkit and that public understanding and support are critical to sustaining effective policy—and that includes countercyclical macro-prudential policy.
Macro-prudential policy tries to assure that the financial system does not amplify shocks and will continue to deliver its essential services, even after severe, unexpected developments. In this context, he discussed the contribution of the countercyclical capital buffer (CCyB) of Basel III. increases in this buffer have come to be used in a number of jurisdictions, as economies and banking systems have recovered from the crisis, including in the UK. Setting this requirement does have its challenges, including identifying and scaling vulnerabilities in environments in which, as is often the case, indicators are giving mixed signals, and then calibrating the appropriate CCyB setting. A second challenge to macro-prudential policy more generally is identifying and dealing with financial vulnerabilities outside the banking system, where they could be lodged in lightly regulated entities and markets. A third challenge is avoiding arbitrage across geographical jurisdictions that simply pushes risk around globally integrated financial markets. According to Mr. Kohn, progress has been made on all three of these fronts since the global crisis, but more remains to be done. Despite these challenges, global financial stability would be better assured if more jurisdictions, including the U.S., adopted a more active use of the CCyB—making sure that banks and other intermediaries retained enough capital in the upswing now going on to safeguard their ability to deliver essential services at reasonable prices in the next downswing.
He said that stress tests are a critical building block for gauging the appropriate level of countercyclical capital. Stress tests should be a key input into a decision about the CCyB, but they are not a substitute for explicitly setting CCyBs. However, the CCyB alone will not be the most efficient or even a sufficient way to mitigate many financial stability risks. For example, mortgage lending against residential real estate has been the culprit in quite a few financial sector problems in many jurisdictions. The externality from troubled housing markets can come from the cutbacks in spending by borrowers who are struggling to service their debt as well as from lenders. The ability to set minimum standards for mortgage lending should be in the tool kit of every macro-prudential authority and that authority should be willing to use it countercyclically. He mentioned that, in this regard, the U.S. falls short of even having the typical macro-prudential tools, much less of an intention to use what controls there are to foster financial stability. Under most circumstances, macro-prudential tools of the sort we have been discussing are likely to be far more effective dealing with financial stability risks than would be the interest rate tools of monetary policy, whose comparative advantage is countering real and price shocks.
As per Mr. Kohn, tightening regulation in good times when the financial system is perceived to be strong, and easing requirements when developments threaten to weaken it, will not be intuitive to many people. Banking lobbies will be opposed to increases in capital requirements or greater restrictions on loan terms; they will try to rally the public to their perspective by citing increased costs of credit. People worried about protecting taxpayers and deposit insurance funds will be hesitant to buy into any relaxation when the cycle turns. Thus, he concluded that “we” need to be active now in explaining to the general public as well as to their elected representatives the public benefits of countercyclical macro-prudential policy and reminding them of the lessons learned about increasing complacency in good times leading to the kinds of serious economic deprivations that were experienced not so many years ago.
Related Link: Speech
Keywords: Europe, UK, Banking, Basel III, CCyB, Macro-prudential Policy, FPC, BoE
Previous ArticleECB Consults on Risk-Specific Chapters of Guide to Internal Models
APRA has concluded its review of the comprehensive plans of authorized deposit-taking institutions for the assessment and management of loans with repayment deferrals.
ESAs (EBA, EIOPA, and ESMA) published the first joint report that assesses risks in the financial sector since the outbreak of the COVID-19 pandemic.
BoE and HM Treasury confirmed that the COVID Corporate Financing Facility (CCFF) will close for new purchases of commercial paper, with effect from March 23, 2021.
ECB published a decision allowing the euro area banks under its direct supervision to exclude certain central bank exposures from the leverage ratio.
ESAs launched a survey seeking feedback on the presentational aspects of product templates under the Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR or Regulation 2019/2088).
ECB published input of the European System of Central Banks (ESCB) into the EBA feasibility report on reducing the reporting burden for banks in EU.
EC adopted a decision determining, for a limited period of time, that the regulatory framework applicable to central counterparties, or CCPs, in the UK and Northern Ireland is equivalent to the requirements laid down in the European Market Infrastructure Regulation (EMIR or Regulation 648/2012).
EBA has decided to phase out the guidelines on legislative and non-legislative moratoria of loan repayments, in accordance with the earlier specified end of September deadline.
EBA published an Opinion addressed to EC to raise awareness about the opportunity to clarify certain issues related to the definition of credit institution in the upcoming review of the Capital Requirements Directive and Regulation (CRD and CRR).
ECB finalized the guide on assessment methodology for the internal model method for calculating exposure to counterparty credit risk (CCR) and the advanced method for own funds requirements for credit valuation adjustment (A-CVA) risk.