PRA published remarks of Sam Woods, the Deputy Governor for Prudential Regulation and Chief Executive Officer of PRA, which were published for the May 2017 Building Society Association Annual Conference. He discussed the importance of supervision in banking and insurance sectors and examined how supervision differs from regulation. He also highlighted that “financial institutions will always be able to innovate faster than we are able to modify the prudential rulebook,” warning that some innovation is “pure regulatory arbitrage.”
Mr. Woods explained that regulation concerns the framework of rules and legal standards that govern the way in which firms operate whereas supervision is the dynamic pursuit of the relevant authority’s statutory objectives, through oversight of firms’ activities. In his view, supervision without regulation, or vice versa, in financial services would be futile. He added that some innovation is “pure regulatory arbitrage," highlighting that firms innovate to reduce specific regulatory requirements without any commensurate reduction in their risk. He gave a few examples of such behavior that might be problematic, despite compliance with the specified rules. For instance, he mentioned that some banks are seeking out funding that matures just beyond the time horizon used to calculate regulatory liquidity requirements. Another example he gave was about how some special purpose vehicles, derivatives, agency structures, or collateral swaps carry material credit risk, which escapes the detailed aspects of the capital framework. He also exemplified that some insurance firms have sought to amend the existing contracts to extend the (Solvency II) contract boundary and recognize more future profit, as firms cannot recognize future premiums on unit-linked savings policies that do not include any insurance cover or financial guarantee of benefits. In this context, he stated that “Consistent with the PRA’s statutory duty, firms should expect questions and should be prepared to defend them according to our principles of prudence, effective risk management, and adequacy of financial resources at all times.”
He observed that “The supervisory approach for banks, building societies, and insurers in the UK has meandered down different paths, at different times—and each at a different pace. Indeed, even when regulation has been laid down in statute, each supervisory agency has taken time to develop and embed its own approach.” PRA supervisors also pay close attention to the emerging trends and potential future risks and supervisors will continue to keep a close eye on the effects of issues on the viability of business models and future strategy for building societies. Finally, he reinforced “that supervision—as distinct from regulation—is vital if we are to ensure that the framework of regulation operates effectively and as intended. Supervisors have an important job to do—defending the reforms put in place following the most recent crisis.”
Related Link: Speech (PDF)
Keywords: Europe, United Kingdom, PRA, Supervision, Banking, Insurance, Regulatory Arbitrage
EBA finalized the two sets of draft regulatory technical standards on the identification of material risk-takers and on the classes of instruments used for remuneration under the Investment Firms Directive (IFD).
EC published, in the Official Journal of the European Union, a notification that the European Court of Auditors (ECA) has published a special report on resolution planning in the Single Resolution Mechanism.
BoE published a scenario against which it will be stress testing banks in 2021, in addition to setting out the key elements of the 2021 stress test, guidance on the 2021 stress test, and the variable paths for the 2021 stress test.
PRA published a consultation paper (CP3/21) proposes rules regarding the timing of identity verification required for eligibility of depositor protection under the Financial Services Compensation Scheme (FSCS).
FSB published the work program for 2021, which reflects a strategic shift in priorities in the COVID-19 environment.
FCA announced that 50% firms have started using the new data collection platform RegData, which is slated to replace the existing platform known Gabriel.
Bundesbank published Version 5.0 of the derivation rules for completeness check at the form level, with respect to the data quality of the European harmonized reporting system.
FED finalized a rule that updates capital planning requirements to reflect the new framework from 2019 that sorts large banks into categories, with requirements that are tailored to the risks of each category.
ECB published results of the quarterly lending survey conducted on 143 banks in the euro area.
ESAs published the final draft implementing technical standards on reporting of intra-group transactions and risk concentration of financial conglomerates subject to the supplementary supervision in EU.