September 15, 2017

Danièle Nouy, Chair of the ECB Supervisory Board, spoke at the 33rd SUERF Colloquium in Helsinki. She discussed the regulatory arbitrage challenges facing regulators and supervisors and highlighted the importance of international supervisory cooperation to deal with this issue.

ECB’s ongoing targeted review of internal models at over 60 banks, including all eight of the globally significant banks supervised in the euro area, is an important step toward dealing with the challenge of regulatory arbitrage. Supervisors need to scrutinize what bankers do and examine individual transactions to see whether they might be an attempt to game the rules. Ms. Nouy discusses three types of regulatory arbitrage and how it can be dealt with:

Cross-Jurisdiction Arbitrage, which exploits differences in rules for banks from one country to another. In Europe, cross-jurisdiction arbitrage has become even more of an issue in the context of Brexit. Thus, harmonization of rules is a powerful tool when it comes to preventing cross-jurisdiction arbitrage. Transposing the Basel and European rules into national law is important in this context, thus making a case for further harmonizing the European rulebook. To that end, we should rely less on EU directives and more on EU regulations, which are directly applicable in all member states.

Cross-Framework Arbitrage, which arises because some parts of the financial sector, such as the shadow banking sector, are less regulated than the highly regulated banking sector. If banks shift exposures to shadow banks, they become vulnerable to what is known as “step-in risk,” which must be addressed. With this in mind, BCBS has made step-in risk part of its official work program and is working on guidelines for banks and supervisors. These guidelines contain a number of criteria that will help to assess step-in risks for individual banks and they propose measures aimed at helping banks to deal with such risks. The guidelines will not contain automatic Pillar 1 capital or liquidity add-ons. Instead, they will provide a list of potential measures that leverage existing tools. It will be up to the banks to choose the most appropriate measures, while supervisors will check and challenge the choices banks make.

Intra-Framework Arbitrage, in which rather than trying to exploit differences between two or more sets of rules, banks try to exploit loopholes within a single set of rules. Here, ECB is more concerned with closing loopholes rather than harmonizing rules and preventing the spillover of risks. One solution could be to change the rules in such a way that loopholes are closed. However, for this to be effective, regulators would first have to identify every loophole, which we all know is impossible. So it makes sense to also apply tools that have a broader and more preventive effect: such measures are already being implemented. The rules nowadays focus on more than one dimension. "Thanks to Basel III, banks around the world now face multiple constraints: the risk-weighted capital ratio has been supplemented by a leverage ratio and liquidity ratios. These constraints reinforce each other, which makes it much more difficult for banks to game them."

 

Related Link: Speech

Keywords: Europe, EU, Banking, Regulatory Arbitrage, Shadow Banking, Step-in Risk, Single Rulebook, ECB

Related Articles
News

BCBS and IOSCO Extend Implementation of Final Phase of Margin Rules

BCBS and IOSCO agree to one-year extension of the final implementation phase of the margin requirements for non centrally cleared derivatives.

July 23, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
News

APRA Proposes Stronger Remuneration Requirements in Australia

APRA is proposing to strengthen prudential requirements for remuneration across all APRA-regulated entities in the banking, insurance, and superannuation industries by issuing CPS 511, a new prudential standard on remuneration.

July 23, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
News

PRA Consults on Availability of Group Own Funds Under Solvency II

PRA published a consultation paper (CP16/19) that sets out its proposed approach to the determination of the availability of subordinated liabilities and preference shares in group own funds.

July 22, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
News

EIOPA Consults on Methodological Principles for Insurer Stress Testing

EIOPA published a discussion paper on the methodological principles for stress testing the insurance sector in EU.

July 22, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
News

US Agencies Adopt Rule to Exclude Community Banks from Volcker Rule

US Agencies (CFTC, FDIC, FED, OCC, and SEC) adopted a final rule to exclude community banks from the Volcker Rule, in line with amendments to certain sections of the Economic Growth, Regulatory Relief, and Consumer Protection (EGRRCP) Act.

July 22, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
News

US Agencies Adopt Amendments to Simplify Regulatory Capital Rules

US Agencies (FDIC, FED, and OCC) adopted a final rule that reduces regulatory burden by simplifying several requirements in the regulatory capital rules for banks.

July 22, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
News

IA of Hong Kong Delegates Inspection and Investigation Powers to HKMA

HKMA and IA of Hong Kong jointly issued a statement announcing the delegation of the inspection and investigation powers of IA to HKMA, pursuant to the statutory regulatory regime for insurance intermediaries under the Insurance Ordinance.

July 19, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
News

FSB Extends Implementation Timeline for Policy Recommendations on SFTs

FSB announced adjustments to the implementation timelines for its recommendations on securities financing transactions (SFTs), specifically those related to the minimum haircut standards for non-centrally cleared SFTs.

July 19, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
News

EBA Single Rulebook Q&A: Third Update for July 2019

EBA published answers to six questions under the Single Rulebook question and answer (Q&A) tool this week.

July 19, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
News

EBA Report Assesses Regulatory Framework for Fintech Activities

EBA published the findings of its analysis on the regulatory framework applicable to fintech firms when accessing the market.

July 18, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
RESULTS 1 - 10 OF 3494