ISDA, in collaboration with certain other entities, published four whitepapers analyzing the legal issues associated with using smart derivatives contracts using the distributed ledger technology or DLT. The papers consider the private international law, or conflict-of-law, aspects of derivatives contracts involving DLT, commonly known as the blockchain technology. The four papers consider these issues from the perspective of the laws in France, Ireland, Japan, and New York. The analysis in each of these jurisdictions concludes that it is unlikely a local court would reject an express choice of law by the contracting parties, whether under ISDA documentation or in any other agreement between the parties and a platform provider. ISDA also published a comparative table that presents high-level responses to the various conflict-of-law issues raised in these papers.
The papers highlight potential challenges in identifying the precise location of digital assets, which could lead to uncertainty over which jurisdiction’s laws would apply. In response, it is recommended that parties agree on a uniform choice of law that will govern all transactions conducted on the DLT platform. Specifically, the papers cover:
- Whether the introduction of DLT or a DLT platform provider to a traditional trading relationship might have implications for the resolution of contractual disputes.
- How to identify the legal situs of digital assets for effecting payments or exchanging collateral on certain DLT platforms.
Through this analysis, ISDA hopes to support the work of international standard-setting bodies, regulators, judiciaries, market participants, and other key stakeholders in examining these issues. The papers are also intended to provide more certainty to participants incorporating DLT into derivatives transactions, thus strengthening the ability of the industry to realize the operational and cost efficiencies provided by greater automation.
The development and implementation of new technologies, such as DLT, within the derivatives industry have the potential to create a more robust financial markets infrastructure, achieve operational efficiencies through increased automation, and reduce costs for market participants. As these technologies mature, it is important to understand the evolving legal treatment of derivatives traded on DLT platforms. Given the novel complications over where data, assets, and even counterparties are located in a DLT environment, it is useful to examine key questions on how to determine which law applies and how to evaluate conflicts of governing law. While some jurisdictions have produced analysis on areas of perceived legal uncertainty, these issues remain untested in many of the jurisdictions and cross-border environments important to the derivatives industry.
- Press Release
- Paper on French Law (PDF)
- Paper on Irish Law (PDF)
- Paper on Japanese Law (PDF)
- Paper on New York Law (PDF)
- Comparative Table (PDF)
Keywords: International, Banking, Securities, Blockchain, Fintech, Regtech, Distributed Ledger Technology, Smart Contracts, Derivatives
The Central Bank of the Philippines (BSP) issued communications covering developments related to online lending platforms, open finance framework and roadmap, and on the expected regulations in the area sustainable finance.
The Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (FED) published the final rule that amends Regulation I to reduce the quarterly reporting burden for member banks by automating the application process for adjusting their subscriptions to the Federal Reserve Bank capital stock, except in the context of mergers.
The European Banking Authority (EBA) published its assessment of risks through the quarterly Risk Dashboard and the results of the Autumn edition of the Risk Assessment Questionnaire (RAQ).
The Malta Financial Services Authority (MFSA) updated the guidelines on supervisory reporting requirements under the reporting framework 3.0.
The Hong Kong Monetary Authority (HKMA) published a circular, along with the reporting form and instructions, for self-assessment, by authorized institutions, of compliance with the Code of Banking Practice 2021.
The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) decided to register European DataWarehouse Ltd and SecRep Limited as securitization repositories under the UK Securitization Regulation, with effect from January 17, 2022.
The European Commission (EC) published the Delegated Regulation 2022/25, which supplements the Investment Firms Regulation (IFR or Regulation 2019/2033) with respect to the regulatory technical standards specifying the methods for measuring the K-factors referred to in Article 15 of the IFR.
The Bank of International Settlements (BIS) published a paper that assesses the ways in which platform-based business models can affect financial inclusion, competition, financial stability and consumer protection.
The Central Bank of Egypt (CBE) published a circular with instructions on emergency liquidity assistance to banks that are unable to meet their liquidity requirements.
The European Supervisory Authorities (ESAs) published the list of identified financial conglomerates for 2021.