BIS Publishes a Working Paper on CoCo Issuance and Bank Fragility
BIS published a working paper on the issuance of contingent convertible capital securities (CoCos) and bank fragility. The promise of CoCos as a bail-in solution has been the subject of considerable theoretical analysis and debate, but little is known about their effects in practice. In this paper, BIS undertakes the first comprehensive empirical analysis of bank CoCos, which represent a market segment comprising over 730 instruments totaling USD 521 billion.
The working paper describes the current state of CoCo issuance and presents an overview of the sample data set. The data set used consists exclusively of CoCos issued by banks and excludes those issued by insurance companies and other non-bank financial institutions. The focus is on CoCos that have at least one (mechanical or discretionary) contractual trigger. The paper highlights that two sets of empirical exercises were conducted. The first exercise examined the determinants of CoCo issuance while the second exercise evaluated the impact of CoCo issuance on the credit default swap (CDS) spreads and equity prices of issuing banks. The empirical analysis leads to the following four main findings:
- The propensity to issue a CoCo is higher for larger and better-capitalized banks
- CoCo issues result in statistically significant declines in issuers' CDS spreads, indicating that they generate risk-reduction benefits and lower costs of debt. This is especially true for CoCos that convert into equity, have mechanical triggers, and are classified as Additional Tier 1 instruments
- CoCos with only discretionary triggers do not have a significant impact on CDS spreads
- CoCo issues have no statistically significant impact on stock prices, except for principal write-down CoCos with a high trigger level, which have a positive effect
CoCos are hybrid capital securities that absorb losses when the capital of the issuing bank falls below a certain level. CoCos can absorb losses either by converting into common equity or by suffering a principal write-down.
Related Link: Working Paper (PDF)
Keywords: International, Banking, CoCo, Basel III, Bank Capital Regulation, BIS
Featured Experts

María Cañamero
Skilled market researcher; growth strategist; successful go-to-market campaign developer

Dieter Van der Stock
IFRS subject matter expert; accounting authority; risk management specialist
Previous Article
EBA Publishes Report Examining Innovative Uses of Consumer DataRelated Articles
News
APRA Issues Operational Risk Rules, Consults on Reporting RequirementsAPRA published an updated prudential standard APS 115 that sets out operational risk requirements for authorized deposit-taking institutions in Australia.
December 11, 2019
WebPage
Regulatory News
|
News
APRA Decides to Keep Countercyclical Capital Buffer for Banks at 0%APRA announced its decision to keep the countercyclical capital buffer (CCyB) for authorized deposit-taking institutions on hold at zero percent.
December 11, 2019
WebPage
Regulatory News
|
News
EBA Issues Revised List of Validation Rules for Reporting by BanksEBA published a revised list of validation rules in its implementing technical standards on supervisory reporting.
December 10, 2019
WebPage
Regulatory News
|
News
SRB Holds Annual Conference, Reflects on Turning Policy into ActionSRB published a report on its fourth annual conference that was held on October 10, 2019 in Brussels.
December 10, 2019
WebPage
Regulatory News
|
News
FED Extends Consultation Period for Capital Requirements for InsurersFED is extending comment period for the proposed rule establishing risk-based capital requirements for depository institution holding companies that are significantly engaged in insurance activities.
December 10, 2019
WebPage
Regulatory News
|
News
OSFI Sets Domestic Stability Buffer Level at 2.25%OSFI has set the Domestic Stability Buffer, or DSB, at 2.25% of total risk-weighted assets, with effect from April 30, 2020.
December 10, 2019
WebPage
Regulatory News
|
News
FSB Examines Financial Stability Aspects of Bigtech and Cloud ServicesFSB published two reports that consider the financial stability implications from the offering of financial services by bigtech firms and the adoption of cloud computing and data services across a range of functions at financial institutions.
December 09, 2019
WebPage
Regulatory News
|
News
HKMA Proposes Changes to Module on Supervision of Concentration RiskHKMA issued a circular proposing revisions to the Supervisory Policy Manual module CR-L-1 on consolidated supervision of concentration risks under the Banking (Exposure Limits) Rules (BELR) Rule 6.
December 09, 2019
WebPage
Regulatory News
|
News
BoE Updates XBRL Filing Manual for Reporting Under Solvency IIBoE has updated the XBRL filing manual (to Version 5.0) to help firms and software vendors create XBRL instance documents for Solvency II Pillar 3 and BoE Insurance reporting.
December 09, 2019
WebPage
Regulatory News
|
News
APRA Specifies Capital Treatment of Equity Investments in ABGFAPRA published a letter to the authorized deposit-taking institutions outlining the regulatory capital treatment of their equity investments in the Australian Business Growth Fund (ABGF).
December 09, 2019
WebPage
Regulatory News
|