Featured Product

    ESMA Identifies Supervisory Deficiencies in Wirecard Reporting Case

    November 03, 2020

    ESMA published the results of its fast-track peer review, which assessed the events leading to the collapse of Wirecard AG and the supervisory response by BaFin and the Financial Reporting Enforcement Panel (FREP). The peer review identifies a number of deficiencies, inefficiencies, and legal and procedural impediments. These concern the independence of BaFin from issuers and government, market monitoring by both BaFin and FREP, examination procedures of FREP, and effectiveness of supervisory system in the area of financial reporting. The review also provides recommendations to address these shortcomings.

    The peer review focuses on the application by BaFin and FREP of the Guidelines on Enforcement of Financial Information (GLEFI) and on impediments to the effectiveness of the German two-tier supervisory system for financial reporting in the context of the Wirecard case. ESMA identified deficiencies in the application of the GLEFI in the Wirecard case in the following areas:

    • Independence of BaFin from issuers and government—BaFin lacks information about employees’ shareholdings. This raises doubts on the robustness of internal control system of BaFin regarding conflicts of interest of its employees vis-à-vis issuers. For BaFin, there is a heightened risk of influence by the Ministry of Finance given the frequency and detail of reporting by BaFin, sometimes before actions were taken. The Peer Review Committee recommends that BaFin should introduce a robust control framework to address the circumstances in which a conflict of interest could arise. The Peer Review Committee recommends that BaFin should introduce stricter limitations to the detail and frequency of reporting to the Ministry of Finance in the context of ongoing examinations. 
    • Market monitoring by both BaFin and FREP—Non-selection (or non-timely selection) of Wirecard’s financial reports for examination based on risks in the period between 2016 and 2018. 
    • FREP’s examination procedures of Wirecard financial reports—The scope of the examinations did not appropriately address areas material to the business of Wirecard, nor the media and whistleblowing allegations against Wirecard. The analyses performed (level of professional skepticism, timeliness of examination procedures, assessment of disclosures) and their documentation were insufficient. The Peer Review Committee recommends that, when establishing the risk factors to be considered to identify abstract risks, FREP should consider, more prominently, indicators of the potential impact of an infringement on financial markets.
    • Effectiveness of the supervisory system in the area of financial reporting—Regarding the respective roles of BaFin and FREP in the case of (indications of) fraud in financial reporting, BaFin and FREP are not aligned in the perception of each other’s role and the limitations and possibilities that both have in the context of the two-tier system. BaFin was not put in the position to thoroughly assess FREP’s examinations of Wirecard, which would have enabled BaFin to determine whether it should take over the examinations from FREP. The strong confidentiality regime, by which both institutions are bound, may have hindered the exchange of relevant information between them and with other relevant bodies. Instances of lack of coordination and inefficiency in exchange of information between relevant teams in BaFin.

    On June 22, 2020, Wirecard announced that EUR 1.9 billion were missing, which it claimed to hold in escrow accounts. In view of allegations of fraud, questions were raised about the roles of BaFin and FREP in taking timely action in this case. The report was prepared in response to a request received from EC on June 25, inviting ESMA to conduct a fact-finding analysis of the events leading up to the collapse of Wirecard AG. This is the first peer review conducted by ESMA under the revised ESMA Regulation and the new Peer Review Methodology, in the form of a Fast Track procedure and focusing on only one jurisdiction and one issuer.

     

    Related Links

    Keywords: Europe, Germany, Banking, Securities, Peer Review, Wirecard, Financial Reporting, FREP, BaFin, EC, ESMA

    Related Articles
    News

    EC Regulation Sets Out Standards for Reporting and Disclosure of MREL

    EC published the Implementing Regulation 2021/763 that lays down implementing technical standards for supervisory reporting and public disclosure of the minimum requirement for own funds and eligible liabilities (MREL).

    May 12, 2021 WebPage Regulatory News
    News

    EBA Report Notes Loan Origination Should Remain in Supervisory Focus

    EBA published a report that examines the convergence of prudential supervisory practices in 2020 and offers conclusions of the EBA college monitoring activity.

    May 12, 2021 WebPage Regulatory News
    News

    APRA Decides to Standardize Submission Date for Quarterly Reporting

    APRA announced the standardization of quarterly reporting due dates for authorized deposit-taking institutions.

    May 11, 2021 WebPage Regulatory News
    News

    ECB Working Group Publishes Recommendations on EURIBOR Fallbacks

    The private sector working group of ECB on euro risk-free rates published the recommendations to address events that would trigger fallbacks in the Euro Interbank Offered Rate (EURIBOR)-related contracts, along with the €STR-based EURIBOR fallback rates (rates that could be used if a fallback is triggered).

    May 11, 2021 WebPage Regulatory News
    News

    Bundesbank Publishes Supporting Documentation for Reporting by Banks

    Bundesbank published a list of "EntryPoints" that are accepted in its reporting system; the list provides taxonomy version and name of the module against each EntryPoint.

    May 11, 2021 WebPage Regulatory News
    News

    EBA Publishes Phase 1 of Reporting Framework 3.1

    EBA published the phase 1 of its reporting framework 3.1, with the technical package covering the new reporting requirements for investment firms (under the implementing technical standards on investment firms reporting).

    May 10, 2021 WebPage Regulatory News
    News

    IOSCO Sees Support for Mandatory Sustainability Reporting

    The Sustainable Finance Taskforce of IOSCO held two roundtables, with global stakeholders, on the IOSCO priorities to enhance the reliability, comparability, and consistency of sustainability-related disclosures and to collect views on the practical implementation of a global system architecture for these disclosures.

    May 10, 2021 WebPage Regulatory News
    News

    APRA to Finalize Capital Adequacy Standard Revisions by January 2022

    Asia Pacific Australia Banking APS 111 Capital Adequacy Regulatory Capital Basel RBNZ APRA

    May 10, 2021 WebPage Regulatory News
    News

    ESMA Issues Guidelines on Outsourcing to Cloud Service Providers

    ESMA published the final guidelines on outsourcing to cloud service providers.

    May 10, 2021 WebPage Regulatory News
    News

    EBA Publishes Data on Deposit Guarantee Schemes

    EBA published annual data for two key concepts and indicators in the Deposit Guarantee Schemes (DGS) Directive—available financial means and covered deposits.

    May 10, 2021 WebPage Regulatory News
    RESULTS 1 - 10 OF 6967