Peter Kohlhagen of APRA on Combating Complacency in PHI Sector
Peter Kohlhagen, APRA’s Senior Manager of Policy Development, spoke about combating complacency in a new era of Private Health Insurance (PHI) instability, at the Health Insurance Summit in Sydney. He built on the importance of resilience in the face of sustainability challenges and updated the audience on APRA’s work with insurers on the Prudential Policy Roadmap, including exploring APRA’s initial thinking on reviewing the capital standards.
He said: “APRA is working with industry to implement a prudential framework that supports insurers to build resilience, so that they are sustainable in the long term. However, no amount of policy, process or regulation can succeed without insurers thinking deeply about what could go wrong—and taking action early.” As per Mr. Kohlhagen, a robust stress testing program, which complements regulatory capital requirements, is one antidote to complacency. “We see evidence that current stress testing practices fall well short of those in other APRA-regulated industries” and “we expect to see a material strengthening of stress testing practices over time.” He then discussed the state-of-play on the Policy Roadmap, highlighting that APRA expects to release final standards on the role of the Appointed Actuary "very soon" and it is consulting on the first installment of its broader work on operational risk, with a new standard that addresses the increasingly prominent issue of cyber risk. APRA also launched a consultation on the second phase, governance, in February this year, wherein it proposed to strengthen the rules around governance, fitness and propriety, and audit, with effect from July 01, 2019. “With phases 1 and 2 of the Roadmap substantially complete, critical parts of the regulatory architecture have been modernized and made fit for purpose,” he said.
He then examined phase 3, which is capital. As per the Roadmap, APRA did not intend to review the capital standards until 2018-2019. Now the time for review is coming closer. “As our thinking progresses on the review of capital standards, we will release a ‘roadmap for capital.’” He finally discussed the challenges related to sustainability of the industry and examined how APRA uses the sustainability metrics, which include measures on financial performance, capital and liquidity, cross-subsidization and risk equalization, social license (reflects the trust of the community in an industry), membership demographics, and APRA’s own risk ratings of the insurer. With respect to sustainability challenges, “APRA will look to understand how the strategy and financial performance sits within the insurers’ pricing philosophy, capital management, risk management, and business planning. We will also look to understand any corrective action the insurer intends to take regarding the situation.” He concluded that APRA continues to “encourage insurers to step up to the challenge of resisting complacency.”
Related Link: Speech
Keywords: Asia Pacific, Australia, Insurance, Private Health Insurance, Policy Roadmap, Stress Testing, Governance, APRA
Featured Experts

Metin Epözdemir
Metin Epözdemir helps European and African banks with design and implementation of credit risk, stress testing, capital management, and credit loss accounting solutions.

Amnon Levy
Financial researcher; authority in credit portfolio management and AI/ML, risk-based pricing, climate and credit, CECL/IFRS 9; credit and ALM

Emil Lopez
Credit risk modeling advisor; IFRS 9 researcher; data quality and risk reporting manager
Related Articles
BIS Innovation Hub Sets Out Work Program for 2021
BIS Innovation Hub published the work program for 2021, with focus on suptech and regtech, next-generation financial market infrastructure, central bank digital currencies, open finance, green finance, and cyber security.
EC Plans to Consult on Crisis Management and EDIS Framework Revisions
In an article published by SRB, Mairead McGuinness, the European Commissioner for Financial Services, Financial Stability, and Capital Markets Union, discussed the progress and next steps toward completion of the Banking Union.
EBA Finalizes Remuneration Standards for Investment Firms in EU
EBA finalized the two sets of draft regulatory technical standards on the identification of material risk-takers and on the classes of instruments used for remuneration under the Investment Firms Directive (IFD).
ECA Recommends Actions to Enhance Resolution Planning for Banks
EC published, in the Official Journal of the European Union, a notification that the European Court of Auditors (ECA) has published a special report on resolution planning in the Single Resolution Mechanism.
BoE Publishes Key Elements of the 2021 Stress Testing for Banks in UK
BoE published a scenario against which it will be stress testing banks in 2021, in addition to setting out the key elements of the 2021 stress test, guidance on the 2021 stress test, and the variable paths for the 2021 stress test.
PRA Proposes Rules on Identity Verification of Depositor Protection
PRA published a consultation paper (CP3/21) proposes rules regarding the timing of identity verification required for eligibility of depositor protection under the Financial Services Compensation Scheme (FSCS).
FSB Publishes Work Program for 2021
FSB published the work program for 2021, which reflects a strategic shift in priorities in the COVID-19 environment.
FCA Issues Update on Move to New Data Collection Platform
FCA announced that 50% firms have started using the new data collection platform RegData, which is slated to replace the existing platform known Gabriel.
Bundesbank Publishes Derivation Rules for Reporting by Banks
Bundesbank published Version 5.0 of the derivation rules for completeness check at the form level, with respect to the data quality of the European harmonized reporting system.
FED Revises Capital Planning and Stress Testing Requirements for Banks
FED finalized a rule that updates capital planning requirements to reflect the new framework from 2019 that sorts large banks into categories, with requirements that are tailored to the risks of each category.