May 24, 2019

Sam Woods of PRA, while speaking at an event in London, emphasized the importance of continually scanning the horizon to identify problems in the financial system. He presented examples of issues that PRA has identified in the areas of leveraged lending, mortgage market including risk-weights for large banks using internal models, treatment of equity-release mortgage holdings by insurers, and cross-border issues between banking and insurance sectors. He also warned that, unless supervisors keep questioning firms and themselves about the worrying developments in the markets, the work that has been done to make the financial system safer could be reversed.

He mentioned that “horizon-scanning” has been become a strategic priority for PRA after the post-crisis reform period. The horizon-scanning activity aims to preempt and mitigate risks that may arise from firms risking up in ways that are excessive, or not properly controlled or capitalized, and from regulatory arbitrage. Although the new regulatory framework has been partly designed to change firms’ behaviors, as the framework settles down the scope for regulatory arbitrage might arise. He then offered concrete examples of issues that PRA has been working on. He pointed out the risks posed by the substantial bank loan exposures in the form of housing mortgages. Mr. Woods noted that mortgage market has seen a dramatic fall in spreads demanded over the risk-free rate, along with a marked shift in the high-loan-to-value (LTV) share of new lending by building societies. Although these shifts may be well within firms’ management capabilities and should be well-captured by the capital framework, this area requires close attention. 

Another area of concern involves the significant decline, over the last decade, in the UK mortgage risk-weights for large firms using internal models; these risk-weights have declined from an average of 15.1% in 2009 to 9.7% in 2018. Thus, the capital requirement that results from that part of the regime (Pillar 1) has dropped by one-third. It is also notable that the average modeled mortgage risk-weight in the UK is lower than in many other jurisdictions. Regarding the level of risk-weights, a vital mitigant against cyclical modeling of mortgage credit risk is the stress-testing regime, which requires firms to carry the amount of capital they would need to keep lending through a severe housing bust. In some ways it is good if the stress-testing part of the regime (Pillar 2) takes more of the strain, because it results in buffer requirements that should be more usable in a stress than Pillar 1 minima. Moreover, Pillar 2A regime should capture concentration risk and any other aspects not captured by Pillar 1:

  • One way to do this is to compare the risk-weight level to some other crude benchmarks—such comparisons do not raise major worries, but nor do they suggest that risk-weights should be any lower.
  • Another way is to explore more sensitivities in stress-testing and to examine areas where non-linearities arise for higher levels of house price falls than those assumed in the main scenarios. A number of safeguards exist regarding this—moving of firms away from "Point in Time" modeling approaches, the leverage ratio, and (further down the track) the Basel 3.1 output floor. However, despite this, caution is required about any significant further moves down in Pillar 1 risk-weights for UK mortgages.

The third area of concern is on the insurance side, where a lot of effort has been put into making sure that equity-release mortgage holdings are treated appropriately on insurance companies’ regulatory balance sheets. There has been an excessively wide variation of approaches for these assets at insurance companies, with practices at the more aggressive end of the market presenting a risk to policyholders and to the competition objective. BoE has, therefore, shored up this part of the framework and put in place a much more solid basis for this asset class going forward. Another area that scanners are always interested in is the border zone between banking and insurance. There are a number of cross-border activities that PRA is keeping an eye on. One is the use of credit insurance to optimize capital positions of banks. It is required to ensure that a risk that  disappears from a bank’s capital requirement has genuinely been moved across the border and that the receiving insurer is properly reserving and capitalizing for that liability.

With respect to leverage lending, he highlighted that analysts often adjust leverage measures to remove large one-off costs and account for optimistic future growth in earnings. These add-backs have been growing steadily in recent years, so the risk metrics in an analyst’s company report are increasingly likely to contain some heroic (or unrealizable) assumptions. Compared to this, the move up the risk curve of UK lenders in the mortgage market looks rather benign. Regulators are required to make sure that both moves are properly managed and capitalized in the firms. Mr. Woods highlighted that, although the leverage ratio is sometimes presented as a simple measure, it is not straightforward as some important judgments go into calculating what banks’ exposures are for leverage ratio purposes. One area that requires close attention is where similar forms of financing—specifically repo, collateral swaps, and synthetic prime brokerage—are captured differently in the leverage exposure measure. Of these, the most important one to watch is collateral swaps. In conclusion, he reiterated that horizon-scanning will be an important part of the BoE effort in the coming period.

 

Related Link: Speech

 

Keywords: Europe, UK, Banking, Insurance, Horizon-Scanning, Financial Stability, Mortgage, Stress Testing, Pillar 1, Pillar 2, CCR, Leverage Ratio, PRA, BoE

Related Articles
News

EBA Consults on Guidelines for Loan Origination and Monitoring in EU

EBA launched a consultation on the guidelines on loan origination and monitoring in EU.

June 19, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
News

OCC Bulletin on Risk Management Guidance for Home Mortgage Lending

OCC published Bulletin 2019-28 on risk management guidance for higher-loan-to-value (LTV) lending activities in communities targeted for revitalization.

June 19, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
News

IFRS to Discuss Phase II of IBOR Reform at July Meeting of ASAF

IFRS published agenda papers for the Accounting Standards Advisory Forum (ASAF) meeting to be held on July 11–12, 2019.

June 19, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
News

EC Amends Regulation Supplementing Solvency II Directive

EC published the Delegated Regulation (EU) 2019/981 that amends the Regulation (EU) 2015/35, which supplements Solvency II Directive (2009/138/EC) on the taking-up and pursuit of the business of insurance and reinsurance.

June 18, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
News

IOSCO Report Examines Application of International Cyber Standards

IOSCO published a final report that examines the application of the three internationally recognized cyber standards and frameworks by IOSCO member jurisdictions.

June 18, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
News

PRA Launches 2019 Stress Test Exercise for Life and General Insurers

PRA has launched the biennial insurance stress test and is asking the largest regulated life and general insurers to provide information about the impact of a range of stress tests on their business.

June 18, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News

SRB Outlines Upcoming Changes in Context of CRR2 and BRRD2

SRB published presentations made at the 8th Industry Dialogue in Brussels.

June 18, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
News

EC Publishes Guidelines on Climate-Related Information Reporting

EC published the guidelines and associated frequently asked questions (FAQs) on corporate climate-related information reporting, as part of its sustainable finance action plan.

June 18, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
News

PRA Finalizes Reporting Amendments to Pillar 2 Liquidity Framework

PRA published the final Policy Statement PS13/19 on regulatory reporting amendments and clarifications to the Pillar 2 liquidity framework for banks in UK.

June 17, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
News

FSB Assesses Implementation of Compensation Standards and Principles

FSB published the sixth progress report on the implementation of its principles and standards for sound compensation practices in financial institutions.

June 17, 2019 WebPage Regulatory News
RESULTS 1 - 10 OF 3276