ESRB published a report that examines the concerns about procyclicality from the expected credit loss (ECL) model in IFRS 9, including the possible sources of procyclicality and its relevance from a financial stability perspective. The report also incorporates the recent information on the implementation of IFRS 9 by EU banks.
Given the limited experience with IFRS 9 to date, this report focuses on describing the aspects of the ECL model under IFRS 9 that could potentially contribute to procyclical bank behavior, along with the conditions under which such behavior would be more likely to arise. The report is focused on the impact at the onset of a downturn because it is a crucial time for the exacerbation of the depth and duration of a financial crisis. The report concludes that a substantial degree of uncertainty exists about the cyclical behavior of the ECL model in IFRS 9 and its impact on bank behavior. Stress tests and targeted and harmonized disclosures are effective tools to improve the understanding of this cyclical behavior. So far, experience of IFRS 9 is limited but points to the following three factors that are important in shaping the cyclical behavior of ECL approach in IFRS 9 and, therefore, may warrant closer monitoring and review going forward:
- The principles-based nature of IFRS 9, with particular reference to the conditions and criteria that trigger the transfer of exposures from stage 1 (12 month expectation) to stage 2 (lifetime expectation) and further into stage 3, which, in turn, could facilitate a delay in loss recognition.
- The ability of, and incentives for, banks to promptly incorporate into their ECL models all new information available on the expected trend of the economic cycle and to recognize losses in a timely manner under IFRS 9 (if recognition of credit losses is delayed because of inadequate modeling or improper incentives).
- The use of point-in-time (PIT) estimates for expected credit losses should generate more volatile outcomes than through-the-cycle estimates, although that volatility should not be judged as negative per se and becomes less relevant if a bank has anticipated the downturn.
The report also concludes that the policy analysis should focus on how the requirements of IFRS 9 are being applied and whether banks have appropriate incentives to recognize credit losses in a timely manner. As IFRS 9 has only been applied since January 01 2018 and in a period of benign macroeconomic conditions, it is still too early to say whether IFRS 9 poses a real risk to financial stability and, therefore, requires prompt regulatory intervention. However, early evidence points to issues that regulators and supervisors may want to monitor closely going forward. These issues, which relate to the quality of foresight in banks’ ECL models, concern lack of information (for example, due to insufficient data or inherent behavioral biases to overweight more recent conditions or not consider tail events) and perverse incentives (that is, management incentives to avoid excessive volatility or adverse market perceptions rather than to build sufficient foresight into ECL estimates). The development of best practices or enhanced guidelines could make a positive contribution to ensuring that the financial stability benefits of IFRS 9 are reaped.
Related Link: Report (PDF)
Keywords: Europe, EU, Accounting, Banking, Procyclicality, ECL, IFRS 9, Credit Risk, Financial Stability, ESRB
HKMA announced that enhancements will be made to the Special 100% Loan Guarantee of the SME Financing Guarantee Scheme (SFGS) and the application period will be extended to December 31, 2021.
BoE has set out a three-phased plan to transform data collection from the UK financial sector over the next decade.
BIS recently made a couple of announcements with respect to the planned and ongoing work in the area of financial technology.
ESRB updated the list of national macro-prudential measures applied by each member state in the European Economic Area.
BoE has set out results of a survey on the impact of COVID-19 events on the use of machine learning and data science.
In response to a request from the European Council and Parliament, ECB published an opinion on the proposed regulation on markets in crypto-assets.
APRA announced the updated aggregate amounts for the 2021 Committed Liquidity Facility (CLF) established between the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) and certain locally incorporated authorized deposit-taking institutions that are subject to the Liquidity Coverage Ratio (LCR).
ECB published supervisory Memorandums of Understanding (MoUs) with UK as well as other European and non-European authorities.
EIOPA identified business model sustainability and adequate product design as the two EU-wide strategic supervisory priorities.
After considering comments received on the November 2020 proposal, US Agencies (FDIC, FED and OCC) are proceeding with the proposed revisions to the reporting forms and instructions for Call Reports FFIEC 031, FFIEC 041, and FFIEC 051.