Featured Product

    Victoria Saporta of BoE Outlines Ideal Post-EU Regulatory Framework

    March 10, 2020

    While speaking at a conference in London, Vicky Saporta of BoE discussed how banks and other financial firms should be regulated now that UK has left EU. Ms. Saporta sets out a framework for thinking about an ideal system of regulation for the future and argues that the financial system in the UK is more stable because the regulatory authorities are independent. In her speech, she builds on the principles that Sam Woods had set out last year to which any future UK regulatory framework should adhere. She builds on these principles to propose an ideal framework from the perspective of achieving the objectives of BoE. She then looked at whether the existing empirical evidence, including some new research, supports the framework.

    Ms. Saporta maps the principles outlined by Sam Woods last year into three ideal features of the institutional structure of the prudential regulation: dynamism, time consistency, and legitimacy. She highlights that the regulatory authority needs to be given a mandate to achieve legitimacy. A mandate provides a regulator with legitimacy in two ways. First, it ensures there is democratic control over the shape of the regulatory regime; for example, the objective or objectives of the prudential regulation, the types of firm in scope, and the issues the regulator must have regard to in making policy. Second, it makes possible to hold the regulator to account. 

    Next, she sets out four alternative models for the institutional structure for prudential regulation. In the first model, prudential regulation is specified in primary legislation. In the second model, prudential regulatory power-setting could lie with government ministers. In the third model, these powers could be given to an independent regulatory body. This model is likely to ensure that prudential regulation is both dynamic and time-consistent. An expert regulator would be able to identify and implement necessary dynamic adjustments, and, for reputation reasons, it would have an incentive to maintain prudential standards provided that it avoided industry capture. However, in the absence of further accountability mechanisms to enhance it, this model would lack legitimacy. Keeping this in mind, she sets out and advocates the fourth model of prudential regulation. 

    This fourth model involves an independent regulatory body with a clear mandate set out in primary legislation and a clear set of accountability mechanisms to Parliament. This model combines the benefits of an expert regulator that can adjust prudential regulation dynamically, with an objective that incentivizes the regulator to maintain prudential standards, while using the mandate and the accountability mechanisms to ensure legitimacy. In theory at least, this fourth model is preferable because, unlike the other models, it possesses all three of the ideal features, according to Ms. Saporta. In this context, she also examines the mandates of various financial sector regulators in the UK. She highlights that this model of independent regulators with mandates making rules is common practice in most jurisdictions outside the UK. Finally, she discusses the evidence supporting the theory that the independence of prudential regulation increases financial stability with no cost to efficiency.

     

    Related Links

    Keywords: Europe, EU, UK, Banking, Post-Brexit, Regulatory Framework, Brexit, Victoria Saporta, BoE

    Related Articles
    News

    EC Adopts Financial Reporting Changes Arising from Benchmark Reforms

    EC published Regulation 2021/25 that addresses amendments related to the financial reporting consequences of replacement of the existing interest rate benchmarks with alternative reference rates.

    January 14, 2021 WebPage Regulatory News
    News

    BIS Bulletin Examines Key Elements of Policy Response to Cyber Risk

    BIS published a bulletin, or a note, that examines the cyber threat landscape in the context of the pandemic and discusses policies to reduce risks to financial stability.

    January 14, 2021 WebPage Regulatory News
    News

    HMT Updates List of Post-Brexit Equivalence Decisions in UK

    HM Treasury, also known as HMT, has updated the table containing the list of the equivalence decisions that came into effect in UK at the end of the transition period of its withdrawal from EU.

    January 14, 2021 WebPage Regulatory News
    News

    EBA Issues Erratum for Technical Package on Reporting Framework 3.0

    EBA published an erratum for technical package on phase 1 of the reporting framework 3.0.

    January 14, 2021 WebPage Regulatory News
    News

    APRA Publishes FAQ on Measurement of Credit Risk Weighted Assets

    APRA updated a frequently asked question (FAQ), for authorized deposit-taking institutions, on the measurement of credit risk weighted assets.

    January 14, 2021 WebPage Regulatory News
    News

    EBA Publishes Risk Dashboard for Third Quarter of 2020

    EBA published the quarterly risk dashboard, along with the results of the Risk Assessment Questionnaire survey among 60 banks and 15 market analysts.

    January 13, 2021 WebPage Regulatory News
    News

    ECB Analysis Shows Privacy as Biggest Concern in Use of Digital Euro

    ECB concluded the public consultation on the introduction of a digital euro in EU.

    January 13, 2021 WebPage Regulatory News
    News

    ECB Finalizes Guide on Supervisory Approach to Bank Consolidation

    ECB published a guide that sets out the supervisory approach to consolidation in the banking sector.

    January 12, 2021 WebPage Regulatory News
    News

    SRB Chair Outlines Work Priorities for 2021

    The SRB Chair Elke König published an article setting out work priorities for 2021.

    January 11, 2021 WebPage Regulatory News
    News

    FDIC Selects Companies to Compete in Final Phase of Tech Sprint

    FDIC has selected 11 technology companies—including BearingPoint, Fed Reporter, Inc, and S&P Global Market Intelligence, LLC—for inclusion in the third and final phase of the rapid prototyping competition.

    January 11, 2021 WebPage Regulatory News
    RESULTS 1 - 10 OF 6417