Featured Product

    S.P. Kothari of SEC Speaks on Policy Challenges Stemming from Big Data

    July 13, 2019

    S.P. Kothari, the Chief Economist and Director of the Division of Economic and Risk Analysis of SEC, spoke at the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER) conference on big data and high-performance computing. He highlighted the policy challenges that stem from big data and these challenges are related to security, technology, and communication. He also discussed the research opportunities in the era of big data and examined the benefits of using legal identity identifier (LEI) and tagging for regulatory disclosures and reporting.

    According to Mr. Kothari, the following are the key policy challenges that SEC is facing from big data:

    • Security. The volume, velocity, and variety of big data make security particularly challenging for several reasons. This is because big data are not only harder to store and maintain but big data are also bigger targets for bad actors. Therefore, SEC must be mindful of the data it collects and its sensitive nature. SEC continues to look into whether it can reduce the data it collects or reduce its sensitivity. One example of this is SEC recently modified the submission deadlines for Form N-PORT, to reduce the volume of sensitive information held by SEC. This simple change reduced the cyber risk profile of SEC without affecting the timing or quantity of information that is made available to the public.
    • Technology. He mentioned the technology arms race between trading firms and the media reports about the increasing use of artificial intelligence, machine learning, and related tools. However, deployment of these technologies involve fixed costs that exclude small, fragmented, or less resourceful market players. Additionally, there are cultural differences between organizations that affect not just the choice of which technology to deploy but also the timing of deployment. For example, hedge funds might be able to adopt new technologies such as cloud computing more quickly than pension funds are able to do so. He also pointed out that certain technologies are "inherently challenging for SEC to monitor." To mention just one example, suppose that artificially intelligent algorithmic trading eventually starts spoofing without the knowledge of the algo creator, (Spoofing is a prohibited activity that involves creating and cancelling a large number of trades in an attempt to convey false information about market demand.) how would SEC respond to this development.
    • Communication. A perennial challenge for SEC is to find cost-effective ways to reduce the variety of financial data without loss of substantive information. For instance, SEC has required filers to tag some data using methods such as XML, FIX, FpML, XBRL, and, more recently, Inline XBRL. By dramatically reducing the variety of the data, tagging transitions an electronic document from being human readable into one that is also machine readable. An additional feature of data tagging is network effects. It is well-known that data in tagged 10-Ks can be linked to data from other forms and other firms. Perhaps it is less appreciated that data in tagged documents could be linked across regulatory boundaries and even national boundaries provided the regulator community required similar data tagging. For the SEC, a key benefit of cross-regulator consistency in tagged data is the ability to understand better the nature of the risks in the financial markets. The markets today do not stop at national borders, so looking only at intra-national data provides only a partial picture of the system’s risk.

    Out of the volume, velocity, and variety, perhaps the best way to make future data sets more manageable is by attacking variety, said Mr. Kothari. This is because it is hard to imagine that future finance data sets will have less volume or less velocity than they do today. Structuring disclosures so that they are machine-readable facilitates easier access and faster analyses that can improve decision-making and reduce the ability of filers to hide fraud. Structured information can also assist in automating regulatory filings and business information processing. By tagging the numeric and narrative-based disclosure elements of financial statements and risk-return summaries in XBRL, the disclosure items are standardized and can be immediately processed by software for analyses. This standardization allows for aggregation, comparison, and large-scale statistical analyses that are less costly and more timely for data users than if the information were reported in an unstructured format. Structured data will likely drive future research in corporate finance and macroeconomics.

    Another common big-data problem is accurately and timely connecting disparate big data sets for analyses. This problem is exacerbated by the broad range of identifiers used by federal agencies. A recent report identified 36 federal agencies using up to 50 distinct, incompatible entity identification systems. These differences raise costs and burdens for both federal agencies and their regulated entities. The Global LEI is a unique 20-character alpha-numeric code that offers a single international connector for disparate big data sets while reducing the regulatory burden associated with each agency's unique identification system. The LEI includes "level 1" data that serve as corporate business cards and "level 2" data that show the relationships between different entities. Recently, SEC released rules that mandate the use of LEI when associated with security-based swap transactions. The LEI is now a component of mandatory swaps transaction reporting in the U.S., Europe, and Canada. Mr. Kothari believes that the full benefits of LEI have yet to be realized. As some companies may have hundreds or thousands of subsidiaries or affiliates operating worldwide, more benefits lie ahead as the LEI becomes more widely and comprehensively used. The LEI allows more transparency regarding hierarchies and relationship mapping. This will support better analyses of risks as they aggregate and potentially become systemic tween different entities. 

     

    Related Link: Speech

     

    Keywords: Americas, US, Banking, Securities, Big Data, Policy Challenges, Cyber Risk, Tagging, Reporting, Swaps, LEI, SEC

    Featured Experts
    Related Articles
    News

    EBA Updates List of Validation Rules for Reporting by Banks

    EBA issued a revised list of validation rules with respect to the implementing technical standards on supervisory reporting.

    September 10, 2020 WebPage Regulatory News
    News

    EBA Responds to EC Call for Advice to Strengthen AML/CFT Framework

    EBA published its response to the call for advice of EC on ways to strengthen the EU legal framework on anti-money laundering and countering the financing of terrorism (AML/CFT).

    September 10, 2020 WebPage Regulatory News
    News

    NGFS Advocates Environmental Risk Analysis for Financial Sector

    NGFS published a paper on the overview of environmental risk analysis by financial institutions and an occasional paper on the case studies on environmental risk analysis methodologies.

    September 10, 2020 WebPage Regulatory News
    News

    MAS Issues Guidelines to Promote Senior Management Accountability

    MAS published the guidelines on individual accountability and conduct at financial institutions.

    September 10, 2020 WebPage Regulatory News
    News

    APRA Formalizes Capital Treatment and Reporting of COVID-19 Loans

    APRA published final versions of the prudential standard APS 220 on credit quality and the reporting standard ARS 923.2 on repayment deferrals.

    September 09, 2020 WebPage Regulatory News
    News

    SRB Chair Discusses Path to Harmonized Liquidation Regime for Banks

    SRB published two articles, with one article discussing the framework in place to safeguard financial stability amid crisis and the other article outlining the path to a harmonized and predictable liquidation regime.

    September 09, 2020 WebPage Regulatory News
    News

    FSB Workshop Discusses Preliminary Findings of Too-Big-To-Fail Reforms

    FSB hosted a virtual workshop as part of the consultation process for its evaluation of the too-big-to-fail reforms.

    September 09, 2020 WebPage Regulatory News
    News

    ECB Updates List of Supervised Entities in EU in September 2020

    ECB updated the list of supervised entities in EU, with the number of significant supervised entities being 115.

    September 08, 2020 WebPage Regulatory News
    News

    OSFI Identifies Focus Areas to Strengthen Third-Party Risk Management

    OSFI published the key findings of a study on third-party risk management.

    September 08, 2020 WebPage Regulatory News
    News

    FSB Extends Implementation Timeline for Framework on SFTs

    FSB is extending the implementation timeline, by one year, for the minimum haircut standards for non-centrally cleared securities financing transactions or SFTs.

    September 07, 2020 WebPage Regulatory News
    RESULTS 1 - 10 OF 5796