ESMA and ISDA Respond to Post-Implementation Review on IFRS 9 Standard
The International Swaps and Derivatives Association (ISDA) and the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) issued a letter each, in response to the request for information from the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) on post-implementation review of the classification and measurement requirements in the financial instruments standard IFRS 9. ESMA and ISDA both support the post-implementation review and suggest certain improvements that can be implemented, with ISDA mostly covering aspects that have direct or indirect relevance for derivatives.
Additionally, ISDA notes that two aspects of IFRS 9 classification and measurement, which its members think warrant the Board’s particular consideration, relate to contractual cash flow characteristics as follows:
- For financial assets with environmental social and governance (ESG) features (such as those included in certain lending arrangements), the members recommend this is considered as part of either the loan’s variable profit margin, or a normal lending arrangement. This is consistent with how the members consider these features in the context of meeting their externally published ESG targets and accommodating the needs of borrowers to commit to similar ESG related targets. Recognition of such lending arrangements at amortized cost also ensures that the most decision-useful information on the ESG lending is presented to users of the financial statements.
- Contractually linked instruments is an area in which the members consider that the existing guidance does not meet the objectives for which it was developed. It would benefit from clarification of key definitions and the addition of examples and guidance to better indicate how it should be applied. Consideration should also be given for revising the scope of instruments captured by this guidance.
In its letter, ESMA strongly supports post implementation review as an opportunity to assess how issuers apply in their financial statements the IFRS requirements and how these can be further improved to address any issues that may challenge consistent application, enforceability, and usefulness to users of financial statements. ESMA calls on IASB to provide more guidance on the assessment of whether sales of financial assets are compatible with the business model “held to collect” and the change in the objective of the entity’s business model. It recommends that IASB provide additional guidance and/or examples to assess whether the cash flows of certain assets with sustainability features are cash flows that are solely payments of principal and interest. Considering the increasing importance of this issue, ESMA believes that it should be addressed by IASB in a timely manner outside the post-implementation review. ESMA also recommends for IASB to provide further explanations on assessing when modified financial instruments shall be derecognized, including the criteria for derecognition and practical examples illustrating the application of those criteria. ESMA would welcome further guidance on the question of whether conditions attached to the interest rate should be reflected in the estimates and revisions of expected future cash flows when determining the effective interest rate. ESMA emphasizes that certain fact patterns related to the classification of non-derivative financial instruments as held for trading may warrant further guidance from IASB. The answers to the request for information, as included in Appendix to the letter, are based on the evidence from supervision and enforcement activities undertaken by European enforcers on financial statements, as discussed within the European Enforcers Coordination Sessions (EECS) and the Financial Institutions Task Force (FITF).
Related Links
Keywords: International, Europe, EU, Banking, IFRS 9, Financial Instruments, Post Implementation Review, Credit Risk, Reporting, Sustainable Finance, ESG, Lending, Derivatives, ISDA, IASB, ESMA
Featured Experts

María Cañamero
Skilled market researcher; growth strategist; successful go-to-market campaign developer

Nicolas Degruson
Works with financial institutions, regulatory experts, business analysts, product managers, and software engineers to drive regulatory solutions across the globe.

Dieter Van der Stock
IFRS subject matter expert; LDTI subject matter expert; accounting authority; risk management specialist
Previous Article
FED and OCC Release the 2022 Stress Test Scenarios for BanksRelated Articles
EU Agencies Update LCR Rule and Macro-Prudential Policy Recommendation
The European Commission (EC) published the Delegated Regulation 2022/786 with regard to the liquidity coverage requirements for credit institutions under the Capital Requirements Regulation (CRR).
EBA Publishes Regulatory Standards to Identify Shadow Banking Entities
The European Banking Authority (EBA) published the final draft regulatory technical standards specifying the criteria to identify shadow banking entities for the purposes of reporting large exposures.
EIOPA Examines Physical Climate Risk Exposure, SII Non-Compliance
The European Insurance and Occupational Pensions Authority (EIOPA) published a report assessing insurers' exposure to physical climate change risks
NGFS Report Explores Quantification of Climate Risk Differentials
The Network for Greening the Financial System (NGFS) published two reports to aid central banks and regulators in their oversight of the financial sector and in their central bank operations
EC Publishes Results on Review of Web Accessibility Directive
The European Commission (EC) published the results of a public consultation, held in October 2021, on the review of the Web Accessibility Directive.
MAS Consults on Adjustment Spreads for Conversion of SOR Contracts
The Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) and the SC-STS are jointly consulting, until June 10, 2022, on setting adjustment spreads for the conversion of legacy SOR contracts to SORA reference rate.
OSFI Discusses Benchmark Rate Transition, Sets Out Work Priorities
The Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions (OSFI) published the strategic plan for 2022-2025 and the departmental plan for 2022-23.
EBA Proposes Standards to Support Secondary NPL Markets
The European Banking Authority (EBA) is consulting, until August 31, 2022, on the draft implementing technical standards specifying requirements for the information that sellers of non-performing loans (NPLs) shall provide to prospective buyers.
EU Confirms Agreement on Rules on Cybersecurity and Banking Resolution
The European Council and the Parliament reached an agreement on the revised Directive on security of network and information systems (NIS2 Directive).
EBA Issues Standards for Crowdfunding Service Providers Under ECSPR
The European Banking Authority (EBA) published the final draft regulatory technical standards specifying information that crowdfunding service providers shall provide to investors on the calculation of credit scores and prices of crowdfunding offers.