FED Paper Examines Impact of Current Expected Credit Loss Standard
FED published a working paper that examines the accounting and economic impact of the Current Expected Credit Loss (CECL) standard. The paper presents a framework that captures a simple and relatively direct impact of CECL on credit availability. The CECL standard will soon replace the incurred loss method (ILM) for the recognition of credit losses in financial accounts. The resulting changes to the timing and magnitude of loss allowances will affect the regulatory capital of banks. As the date of implementation approaches, several commentators have raised concerns that the standard will have a “procyclical” impact, reducing lending in downturns. In contrast, the findings in this study suggest that CECL will modestly affect bank lending in a way that dampens fluctuations.
The paper highlights that CECL results in earlier accumulation of allowances prior to recessions than the ILM. This feature of the standard encourages banks to deleverage and raise capital before credit conditions are at their tightest. However, CECL may also result in a larger accumulation of allowances around recessions, potentially encouraging banks to deleverage more. Accounting for both of these effects, CECL would have reduced lending in the lead up to the financial crisis and increased it during the recovery, modestly decreasing the volatility of lending growth. These conclusions are robust to a range of assumptions about banks’ foresight of losses and management of capital ratios. The framework presented in this paper does not incorporate potential effects of CECL on the composition of bank lending and loan pricing., which could further reduce cyclicality. The analysis may overstate the magnitude of the impact of CECL to the extent that
- Banks have significant discretion when modeling CECL allowance for credit losses
- Banks are indifferent to the shorter-term shifts between allowances
- Capital implied by CECL or the capital impact at banks subject to comprehensive capital analysis and review (CCAR) is roughly offset by reductions in the modeled stress losses
Related Links
Keywords: Americas, US, Banking, Accounting, CECL, Regulatory Capital, Incurred Loss Method, CCAR, Research, IFRS 9, FED
Featured Experts
Anna Krayn
CECL adoption expert; engagement manager for loss estimation, internal risk capability enhancement, and counterparty credit risk management
Masha Muzyka
CECL, IFRS 9, and IFRS 17 expert; credit risk and insurance risk specialist; strategic planning and credit analytics solutions consultant
Emil Lopez
Credit risk modeling advisor; IFRS 9 researcher; data quality and risk reporting manager
Previous Article
ESRB Receives Notification on Identification of O-SIIs in DenmarkRelated Articles
PRA Finalizes Policy on Prudent Person Principle Under Solvency II
PRA published the policy statement PS14/20, which contains the supervisory statement SS1/20 and the feedback to responses to the consultation paper CP22/19 on expectations for investment by firms in accordance with the Prudent Person Principle, or PPP, as set out in the Investments Part of the PRA Rulebook.
EBA on Extending Large Exposure Limits for French Systemic Banks
EBA published an opinion following the notification by the French macro-prudential authority, the Haut Conseil de Stabilité Financière (HCSF), of its intention to extend a measure introduced in 2018 on the use of Article 458(9) of the Capital Requirements Regulation (CRR).
ECB Highlights NPL Resolution as Key Policy Issue in Post-COVID Europe
As part of a Research Bulletin on the recent policy-relevant work, ECB published an article that examines the lessons learned from past crises for nonperforming loan resolution in the post COVID-19 period.
RBNZ Publishes Financial Stability Report for May 2020
RBNZ published the financial stability report for May 2020. This review of the financial system in the country highlights that the economic disruption associated with COVID-19 will present challenges to the financial system.
ECB Updates Guidance on Reporting of Securities Holdings Statistics
ECB updated the guidance notes for reporting related to the statistics on holdings of securities by reporting banking groups (SHSG).
ECB Publishes Results of Financial Stability Review in May 2020
ECB published results of the financial stability review in May 2020. Among other issues, the financial stability review assesses operations of the financial system so far during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Regulators and Private Sector Meet to Discuss COVID Policy Responses
Financial policymakers and international standard-setters met virtually with private-sector executives to discuss international policy responses to COVID-19 pandemic.
ESMA Responds to IASB Consultation on Interest Rate Benchmark Reform
ESMA published a letter responding to IASB on the exposure draft on the phase 2 of the interest rate benchmark reform.
HKMA Consults on Supervisory Policy for OTC Derivatives Transactions
HKMA is consulting on revisions to the Supervisory Policy Manual module CR-G-14 on margin and other risk mitigation standards for non-centrally cleared over-the-counter (OTC) derivatives transactions.
EBA Examines Impact of COVID Crisis on Banking Sector in EU
EBA published thematic note presenting a preliminary assessment of the impact of COVID-19 outbreak on the banking sector in EU.
