ESRB published an occasional paper that shows results from the ESRB surveys of the responses of banks and insurance companies to stress tests. The paper describes the surveys and their insights regarding potential adverse feedback loops. The paper does not necessarily characterize current systemic risks, but rather elucidates the value of macro-prudential surveys and discusses the methodological issues that arise in their implementation.
The existing stress tests do not capture feedback loops between individual institutions and the financial system. To identify feedback loops, ESRB has developed macro-prudential surveys that ask banks and insurers how they would behave in a macroeconomic stress scenario. In a pilot application of these surveys, the evidence of herding behavior in the banking sector was noted, particularly concerning credit retrenchment. Results showed that the consequences can be large, potentially undoing the initial effects of banks’ remedial actions by worsening their solvency position. In contrast, insurers’ responses to the survey provided little evidence of herding in response to macroeconomic stress.
These results highlighted the usefulness of macro-prudential surveys in identifying feedback loops. By analyzing survey responses, macro-prudential policymakers can identify systemic risks arising from herding behavior during periods of financial stress. The surveys, therefore, provide a macro-prudential overlay to the large-scale micro-prudential stress tests that have become a cornerstone of the post-crisis financial supervision.
Related Link: Occasional Paper (PDF)
Keywords: Europe, EU, Banking, Insurance, Stress Testing, Financial Stability, Macro-prudential Survey, Systemic Risk, ESRB
Previous ArticleSabine Lautenschläger of ECB on Risk Reduction in the Euro Area
APRA issued a letter to authorized deposit-taking institutions announcing its intent to formalize the capital measures and reporting requirements for COVID-19 loans through temporary legislative instruments.
EBA is inviting relevant stakeholders, such as financial institutions and information and communication technology (ICT) third-party providers, to share their views and experience on the use of regtech solutions through its regtech industry survey.
FCA finalized the guidance extending measures to help customers that hold insurance and premium finance products and are in temporary financial difficulty because of COVID-19 crisis.
BoE published a statistical notice (Notice 2020/9) explaining the approach for treatment of payment holidays on the profit and loss return or Form PL.
FASB announced the launch of its new Post-Implementation Review (PIR) web portal.
EBA revised the draft implementing technical standards on supervisory reporting as part of the reporting framework 3.0.
ECB published report that presents a summary of the analysis conducted on the internal capital adequacy assessment process (ICAAP) practices of a sample of 37 "significant" banks.
EC published a proposal for a regulation that amends the Benchmarks Regulation (2016/1011) regarding the exemption of certain third-country foreign-exchange benchmarks and the designation of replacement benchmarks for certain benchmarks in cessation.
PRA published a letter from Mel Beaman, the Director for UK Deposit Takers, to suspend the relevant guidance levels on fixed rate lending limits in the “Specialist Sourcebook” for an initial period of six months, running from August 01, 2020 to January 31, 2021.
BoE updated the known issues document for the statistical reporting Forms AS and FV.