General Information & Client Services
  • Americas: +1.212.553.1653
  • Asia: +852.3551.3077
  • China: +86.10.6319.6580
  • EMEA: +44.20.7772.5454
  • Japan: +81.3.5408.4100
Media Relations
  • New York: +1.212.553.0376
  • London: +44.20.7772.5456
  • Hong Kong: +852.3758.1350
  • Tokyo: +813.5408.4110
  • Sydney: +61.2.9270.8141
  • Mexico City: +001.888.779.5833
  • Buenos Aires: +0800.666.3506
  • São Paulo: +0800.891.2518
September 2013

Implementing stress testing practices across the various bank divisions is a complex process. In order to address the need for an implementation framework, Moody’s Analytics has created a Seven Steps Model.

The model represents a collection of principles and best practices developed through extensive interviews with many of the stakeholders in our client institutions. It also represents a process to implement a comprehensive, rigorous, and forward-looking stress testing programme.

The findings are summarised in this article’s chart, which highlights key activities for each step in the process. Each step is detailed to further pinpoint opportunities for effectively integrating stress testing in a firm.

Moody’s Analytics has created a Seven Steps Model to help implement stress testing best practices across various bank divisions.
Moody’s Analytics has created a Seven Steps Model to help implement stress testing best practices across various bank divisions.
Source: Moody's Analytics

Step 1: Define scope and governance

Organisational silos, still dominant at many banks, make efficient enterprise-wide stress testing an ongoing challenge. However, banks should establish dedicated teams tasked with defining objectives and governance guidelines and ensuring proper coordination among the business, risk, and finance departments. Such teams often range in size from three to twenty people (based on bank size). Some teams report to the Chief Risk Officer (CRO), others to the Chief Financial Officer (CFO); in both structures, a direct relationship to the board is critical.

Step 2: Define scenarios using a multidisciplinary approach

Many banks use committees to define and review stress scenarios and to reinforce participation across the institutional boundaries. Some organisations have created departments focused on the sole task of developing and managing enterprise stress testing. Such groups typically use external scenarios (such as macroeconomic shocks) as benchmarks that assist in developing specific internal scenarios. Moody’s Analytics recommends this as a best practice. Defining scenarios that are useful to business lines, as well as the risk and finance functions, require the effective participation and cooperation of multiple teams and specialists.

Additionally, embedding risk culture in decision-making across business units and functions, whilst essential, remains a challenge for many banks.

Step 3: Data and infrastructure

Institutions continue to struggle with data quality, availability, and comprehensiveness despite significant investments in both capabilities and infrastructure in recent years. Legacy systems and silos that were developed during the course of Basel II implementation hinder the flexibility required for effective stress testing. Shifting and uncertain regulatory demands also complicate progress in this area. Therefore, a flexible platform for aggregating the balance sheet data that integrates information from across the organisation is crucial.

Steps 4 & 5: Calculate stressed key performance indicators (KPIs)

Once the data is captured and centralised, the next step is to layer on macroeconomic scenarios. Modelling the impact of macroeconomic scenarios on institutional cash flows (e.g., income or economic capital) requires both significant information and a strong understanding of the business drivers.

Quantitative measures – such as probability of default (PD), exposure at default (EAD), and loss given default (LGD) – are of particular interest to senior management as they link stress testing directly to performance. Common implementation challenges include lack of internal skills and data, shortage of relevant resources, time constraints, and a dearth of skilled personnel. Best practices include developing internal models using dedicated quantitative teams, as well as using third-party models and services to accelerate the process, decrease internal workloads, and fill gaps in key skills and capabilities.

Step 6: Reporting

Requirements for stress testing come from a variety of external and internal sources. These include national and supranational regulators, the board of directors, various committee and governance structures, as well as business line management. These requirements will grow and evolve over time, making effective reporting consume an increasing amount of both time and resources.

Reporting tools that address regulatory requirements that can also be leveraged for business purposes will offer significant benefits and should be considered a best practice. At the same time, the lack of common standards for reporting means the size, degree of detail required, and structure of reports will vary widely, so flexibility and the ability to adapt to changing requirements are critical capabilities.

Step 7: Action based on fully engaged senior management

Ultimately, stress testing must be part of both the business planning process and the institution’s day-to-day risk management practice. Adjustments to asset-liability composition should align with management of concentration risk. Monitoring sensitive limits should provide useful input to risk appetite discussions. Yet 80% of surveyed financial institutions fail to integrate stress testing into the senior decision-making process. Best practices in this area remain a work in progress.

In conclusion, investing in efficient tools, processes, and systems should help banks turn what is perceived as a labour-intensive, mainly regulatory exercise into an effective tool for business planning and risk management. Easier compliance with regulation and increased transparency in the marketplace should coincide with more confident decision-making.

Contributors

Charles Stewart and Nicolas Kunghehian also contributed to this article.

As Published In:
Related Insights

IFRS 9 Survey Results

This article is a summary of the views expressed by regional banking institutions in a recent survey about IFRS 9 regulation. The survey was conducted to assess progress, potential challenges, and plans of banks with regards to IFRS 9 compliance.

June 2016 WebPage María C. Cañamero, Michael McDonald, Yagmur Uenal

Global Banking Regulatory Radar

The Moody’s Analytics Regulatory Radar provides an overview of the main regulatory guidelines affecting the banking industry. It is a proprietary tool developed to monitor regulations in the immediate, medium, and long term, across multiple jurisdictions.

December 2015 WebPage María C. Cañamero

Five Challenges for the Business-Model “Bank”

Banks and the services they offer remain essential to global economies.To stay relevant, however, banks need to adjust their business models and adapt to the new realities – tighter regulation, lower interest rates, changing client needs and behavior, technology disruption, and accelerating disintermediation.

December 2015 WebPage Dr. Christian Thun

AnaCredit Gives Banks an Opportunity to Improve Data Management, but Challenges Remain

The AnaCredit project is scheduled to be implemented in three stages by mid-2020. This paper looks at the challenges for banks in creating the AnaCredit framework and how to overcome these main challenges.

July 2015 Pdf Dr. Christian Thun

Strong Data Management – An Absolute Necessity

Inferior data, too long left unchecked, has far-reaching consequences – not the least of which was the 2008 global financial crisis. Banks that establish a strong data management framework will gain a distinct advantage over their competitors and more efficiently achieve regulatory compliance.

May 2015 WebPage Dr. Christian Thun

Outlining a Path From Data Management to Value Generation

Effective Risk Data Aggregation and Reporting stipulate that banks need to have a strong governance framework, risk data architecture and IT infrastructure. This webinar discusses how addressing data quality has become an opportunity for competitive advantage.

April 2015 WebPage Dr. Christian Thun

European Banks Underestimate the Challenges of BCBS 239 Implementation

This whitepaper looks at the results of the Moody's Analytics survey in January 2015, which reveals that many banks underestimate the time, resources and cost involved to implement BCBS 239.

April 2015 Pdf Dr. Christian Thun

Moody's Analytics 2015 Survey on BCBS 239 Compliance

In response to the data challenges faced by banks when preparing their BCBS 239 project, Moody's Analytics has engaged with market participants in EMEA to better understand the current state of the industry by providing a snapshot through our BCBS 239 survey.

February 2015 WebPage Dr. Christian Thun

Global Banking Regulatory Radar

The Global Banking Radar highlights the busy regulatory agenda that banks will face over the next couple of years. The trend of increased regulation that began in the EU and the US is now spreading to other regions, requiring banks worldwide to comply with increasingly stringent and complex requirements.

November 2014 WebPage Avinash Arun, María C. Cañamero

Lean Management: A New Zeitgeist in Risk Management

Banks can greatly benefit from a leaner and more integrated approach to risk management. This article addresses how banks can constantly evolve to an efficient and productive process, by focusing on data, infrastructure, process, and – most importantly – people.

November 2014 WebPage Dr. Christian Thun

Webinar-on-Demand: Stress Testing as a Catalyst for BCBS 239 – or Vice Versa?

Banks will be under even more pressure as stress testing is becoming a recurring exercise and the new principles for risk data aggregation (BCBS 239) require them to quickly solve the issues around the data warehouses.

September 2014 WebPage Dr. Christian Thun

Can the Asset Quality Review Restore Confidence?

The article looks at the ECB's use of the AQR as a building block for restoring confidence within the European Banking System. It also provides an outline of the key elements of the AQR, including collateral and real estate valuation, collective provision analysis, and fair value exposures.

May 2014 Pdf Dr. Christian Thun

Regulatory Radar for Insurance: Emerging Regulations are Reshaping the Global Insurance Industry

The increased focus and attention on the insurance industry are illustrated by the acceleration of regulatory efforts across the globe. Keeping up with the pace of regulatory change in the current environment is one of the greatest challenges facing any insurance company.

May 2014 WebPage María C. Cañamero, Sandy Sharp

Target Architecture for Stress Testing (North America)

The Target Architecture for Stress Testing diagram illustrates the building blocks of a sound enterprise-wide stress testing system. The architecture highlights the need for a solution that will facilitate systems and models integration, data flow coordination, and automated reporting.

November 2013 WebPage María C. Cañamero, Alex Kang

Preparing for the Stress Tests: Regulatory Timeline and Requirements

The Moody’s Analytics Regulatory Timeline provides a high-level overview of the stress testing regulations in both the United States and European Union in the immediate and medium-term.

November 2013 WebPage María C. Cañamero

Leveraging the Regulatory Stress Tests to Build Long-Term Value

Banks have to dedicate enormous resources to comply with CCAR and DFAST, but rather than treating stress testing like a check-the-box exercise, banks should view it as an opportunity to better manage their businesses and invest in robust stress testing frameworks.

November 2013 WebPage Dr. Christian Thun

Target Architecture for Stress Testing (Europe)

The Target Architecture for Stress Testing diagram illustrates the building blocks of a sound enterprise-wide stress testing system. The architecture highlights the need for a solution that will facilitate systems and models integration, data flow coordination, and automated reporting.

September 2013 WebPage María C. Cañamero, Alex Kang

Challenges and Pitfalls of Stress Testing

This article describes stress testing challenges and pitfalls and offers ways to successfully overcome them to comply with the new regulatory guidelines and to establish internal frameworks.

September 2013 WebPage Dr. Christian Thun

Regulatory Radar

The Moody’s Analytics Regulatory Radar is a proprietary tool developed to monitor regulations in the immediate and medium term, across market segments and jurisdictions. This version provides an overview of key rules and regulatory guidelines recently published across Europe in several financial services segments.

September 2013 WebPage María C. Cañamero, Sandrine Prioux

Are Regulatory Stress Tests Just Cost Without Value?

Stress testing is a powerful risk management tool that offers a an opportunity to contemplate potential actions to take depending on different scenarios. Unfortunately, many banks consider regulatory stress testing a burden and not an opportunity. We examine how banks can use the exercise to build long-term value.

September 2013 WebPage Dr. Christian Thun

Common Challenges and Pitfalls in Stress Testing of Banks

Dr. Christian Thun's whitepaper discusses the need for banks to use stress testing as a business management tool that goes beyond regulatory requirements and also highlights key challenges and pitfalls along the way. This paper summarizes discussions with more than 50 leading banks as well as regulators.

February 2013 Pdf Dr. Christian Thun

Common Pitfalls and Challenges in Stress Testing of Banks

This article discusses the challenges and pitfalls associated with embedding a stress testing framework that complies with risk management practices under the new Basel III regulatory guidelines. It also helps to establish internal frameworks that meet the risk appetite of an organisation and lead to a critical review of its current risk profile.

December 2012 Pdf Dr. Christian Thun

Best Practices in Stress Testing

Although the concept of stress testing has been around since the early 1990s, its use by regulators and bank management took on renewed urgency after the collapse of Lehman Bros in 2008. Moody's Analytics surveyed 42 financial institutions in Europe and analyzed the results to identify common patterns and practices and mapped the findings to a seven-step process to create a “Best Practice” perspective. This article provides observations based on Moody's Analytics Stress Testing report 2011, it has been published on Intelligent Risk in February 2012.

January 2012 Pdf Dr. Christian Thun

Reverse Stress Testing: Challenges and Benefits

Reverse stress testing is becoming recognised throughout the world for its benefits. This presentation explains what reverse stress testing is and what it can achieve, along with the challenges it presents. Here we show you why reverse stress testing can lead to a deeper understanding of an organisation's susceptibility to risk and why it is a valuable tool for any risk management strategy.

November 2010 Pdf Dr. Christian Thun, Dr. Juan M. Licari, Mark Zandi