General Information & Client Services
  • Americas: +1.212.553.1653
  • Asia: +852.3551.3077
  • China: +86.10.6319.6580
  • EMEA: +44.20.7772.5454
  • Japan: +81.3.5408.4100
Media Relations
  • New York: +1.212.553.0376
  • London: +44.20.7772.5456
  • Hong Kong: +852.3758.1350
  • Tokyo: +813.5408.4110
  • Sydney: +61.2.9270.8141
  • Mexico City: +001.888.779.5833
  • Buenos Aires: +0800.666.3506
  • São Paulo: +0800.891.2518
July 07, 2017

IMF published its staff report and selected issues report in the context of the 2017 Article IV consultation with Germany. The IMF assessment highlights that regulatory capital in the banking sector is adequate, but profitability continues to be weak, reflecting structural factors, some crisis legacies, and the low interest rate environment. Low interest rates, if prolonged, would also negatively affect life insurers, given their extensive reliance on guaranteed products.

The staff report highlights that German banks are generally well-capitalized in risk-weighted terms, but leverage ratios are low in international comparison, especially for large private banks. The number of banks and branches has declined by about 15% since the financial crisis and this trend is set to continue, as the cost-to-income ratio remains on an uptrend in recent years—partially reflecting higher regulatory costs. Following a second year of large losses, Germany’s global systemically important bank substantially increased capital in March-April 2017 and announced a new restructuring strategy. This is a welcome development and has resulted in a decline in the bank’s CDS spreads. However, it is too early to assess whether the new strategy will be able to sustainably return the bank to profitability. The 2016 Germany FSAP pointed out that a formal coordination framework among authorities that would be involved in crisis management (ECB, the Systemic Risk Board, and the competent German authorities) had yet to be developed, but limited progress has been made in this area till now. The authorities also expressed strong commitment to the new EU bank resolution framework and the concept of bail-in. They also shared staff’s concerns about the need to ensure operational readiness in a systemic crisis, but noted that coordination among national and European authorities still needs to be tested in real-time simulation exercises.

 

The assessment also reveals that solvency buffers of life insurers look comfortable and this owes much to the Solvency II transitional measures. At 286% (on aggregate) at the beginning of 2016, the solvency capital requirement ratio (SCR) for the German life insurance industry was well above the required (100%) minimum and among the highest in Europe. However, some caution is in order when interpreting this figure. Nearly 70% of German life insurers are making use of Solvency II transitional measures. Without these measures, about a third of reporting LI companies (26 insurers) would not have reported sufficient own funds in the first quarter of 2016. The 2016 FSAP and the more recent EIOPA stress tests showed that the German life insurance sector would be severely negatively affected in a “low for long” situation due to large negative duration gaps and the prevalence of guaranteed returns products. New legislation introducing macro-prudential instruments for the real estate market was approved, but left the toolkit incomplete and important data gaps unaddressed. The new legislation broadens the macro-prudential toolkit to include loan-to-value and amortization requirements, but does not include either debt-to-income or debt-service-to-income limits—instruments designed to limit borrower vulnerability to income and interest rate shocks and ensure affordability. Most importantly, the new law does not include any provision for a granular, loan-by-loan database, a central tenet of the past staff recommendation to ensure effective implementation of macro-prudential tools.

 

Related Links

Staff Report (PDF)

Selected Issues Report (PDF)

Keywords: IMF, Germany, Europe, Banking, Insurance, Solvency II, Article IV, Anacredit

Related Insights

IMF Reports on 2017 Article IV Consultation with China

August 15, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

EBA Updates Data Used for the Identification of G-SIIs

August 11, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

Basel III Monitoring Updates for August 2017

August 10, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

ESMA Published Opinions on Position Limits Under MiFID II

August 10, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

FED Updates Reporting Form FR Y-14Q in August 2017

August 08, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

MAS Consults on Revisions to the Deposit Insurance Scheme

August 04, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

EBA Single Rulebook Q&A: First Update for August 2017

August 04, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

EBA Consults on Its Approach to Financial Technology

August 04, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

OCC Seeks Comments on Revising the Volcker Rule

August 02, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

PRA Update on BEEDS Portal UAT for Capital+ Reporting

July 31, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

IAIS Consults on Revisions to ICP 24

July 31, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

EBA Single Rulebook: Final Q&A Updates in July 2017

July 28, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

ESRB Publishes Its Annual Report for 2016

July 28, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

EIOPA Consults on Information Requests on IORPs

July 26, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

Bundesbank Updates Structured Q&A on AnaCredit

July 25, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

EIOPA Q&A on Regulations for July 2017

July 24, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

BOM Updates Guidelines and Guidance Notes in July 2017

July 21, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

OSFI Revises Implementation Timeline for the FRTB Rules

July 20, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

FSB Report on the Peer Review of France

July 20, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

IMF Report on the Use of Supervisory Standards in FSAP

July 20, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

APRA Announces Stronger Capital Benchmarks for Banks

July 19, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

IAIS Newsletter for July 2017

July 18, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

ESMA Updates Q&A on UCITS and AIFMD

July 11, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

ESRB Report on Resolving Non-Performing Loans in Europe

July 11, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

SRB Publishes the 2016 Annual Report

July 11, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

ESMA Updated Q&A on MiFID II/MiFIR Investor Protection

July 10, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

EC Consults on Development of Secondary Market for NPLs

July 10, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

ESMA Updates Q&A on Implementation of MiFID II

July 07, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

ESMA Consults on Simplifications for Prospectuses

July 06, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

ESMA Updated Q&A on Market Abuse Regulation

July 06, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

FSB Progress Report on Financial Regulatory Reforms

July 03, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

FED Reporting Updates for July 2017

July 03, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

EBA Single Rulebook: Final Q&A Updates in June 2017

June 30, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

FSB Reports on Reforms to OTC Derivatives Markets

June 29, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

FED Reporting Updates for June 2017

June 28, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

DNB Issued Banking Newsletter for June 2017

June 28, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

EBA Publishes Annual Consumer Trends Report for 2017

June 28, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

DNB Issues Insurance Newsletter for June 2017

June 28, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

FPC Publishes Financial Stability Report in June 2017

June 27, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

ECB Recommends Amendment to Article 22 of its Statute

June 23, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

HKMA Circular on AML/CFT Amendment Bill 2017

June 23, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

JFSA Consults on BCBS Pillar 3 Disclosure Requirements

June 23, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

PRA Updates SS35/15 on Guidelines for Completing MLAR

June 23, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

HKMA Consultation on Implementation of IRRBB Standards

June 22, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

IAIS Newsletter for June 2017

June 22, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

FCA Update on Regulatory Sandbox Under Project Innovate

June 22, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

EBA Launched 2016 CVA Risk Monitoring Exercise

June 21, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

PRA Published Consultation Paper on Recovery Planning

June 21, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

EBA Responds to the EC Consultation on Fintech

June 15, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

ESAs Published Annual Reports for 2016

June 15, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

EIOPA Q&A on Regulations for June 2017

June 15, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

RBI Accredits Another Credit Rating Agency INFOMERICS

June 13, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

PRA Published CP6/17 on Regulatory Reporting

June 12, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

Bundesbank Updates on AnaCredit Project for June 2017

June 12, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

EC Approved Resolution of Banco Popular

June 07, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

ESMA Chair Says Preparation for MiFID II is on Track

June 07, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

Response of ESMA to EC Consultation on Fintech

June 07, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News

EC Report on Information Barriers in SME Funding Market

June 06, 2017 WebPage Regulatory News